Who Are Top 20 Welterweights of All Time??

[C.Y.]

just gonna throw some names out there


sugar ray robinson
shane mosley
barney ross
tommy hearns
ray leonard
pernell whitaker
wilfred benitez
felix trinidad
oscar de la hoya
henry armstrong
kid gavilan
carmen basilio
jose naples


what yall think?

[IMDAZED]

just gonna throw some names out there


sugar ray robinson
shane mosley
barney ross
tommy hearns
ray leonard
pernell whitaker
wilfred benitez
felix trinidad
oscar de la hoya
henry armstrong
kid gavilan
carmen basilio
jose naples


what yall think?

Everything good but Shane Mosley. Don't think he deserves to be up there. Certainly the 80's welters could go up there before he does (Breland, Starling, Curry). I'd put Margarito up there ahead of Shane too.

[niceguy45]

mosley lost @ 154lbs
fouhgt like 4-5 @ welter

[Dambala]

1-Sugar Ray Robinson
2-Henry Armstrong
3-Sugar Ray Leonard
4-Jose Napoles
5-Tommy Hearns
6-Carmen Basilio
7-Kid Gavilan
8-Tito Trinidad
9-Pernell Whitaker
10-Emile Griffin
11-Oscar De La Hoya
12-Charlie Burley
13-Shane Mosley
14-Barney Ross
15-Roberto Duran

[Silencers]

Mickey Walker, Jack Britton and Ted Lewis deserves mentioning.

[IMDAZED]

mosley lost @ 154lbs
fouhgt like 4-5 @ welter

Yeah, Mosley lost twice to Forrest at 147, and then later in his career lost to Miguel Cotto.

Both he and Oscar hold one significant win at welter, unless you count Oscar's controversial win over a faded Whitaker. I'd place Donald Curry above both.

[C.Y.]

far as mosley goes i personally dont think he's the best at welter i was just throwing some names up there

[Hagler★]

cuevas for the mixer

[Ryn0]

Everything good but Shane Mosley. Don't think he deserves to be up there. Certainly the 80's welters could go up there before he does (Breland, Starling, Curry). I'd put Margarito up there ahead of Shane too.

Margarito? He hasn't done anything other than beat Cintron who's most credible fight was losing to Margarito twice. Shane deserves to be up there more than Breland, Starling and Margarito not Curry though.

[IMDAZED]

Margarito? He hasn't done anything other than beat Cintron who's most credible fight was losing to Margarito twice. Shane deserves to be up there more than Breland, Starling and Margarito not Curry though.

I don't think Shane is higher than Margarito who has beaten more contenders and champs at ww than Shane. Cintron, Lewis, Clottey, Cotto? Yeah, that trumps one Oscar.