Who do you rate higher?

[Fox McCloud]

Andre Berto or Joshua Clottey?

[The Surgeon]

tough 1, right now id say i rate Clottey higher but Berto is still so full of potential

[ALT-Assassin]

Andre Berto or Joshua Clottey?

In the rankings I would go with Joshua Clotty because of who he fought and how he performed against top competition{Margarito,Mayweather,Judah}but in terms of overall skill I would pick Berto.The problem is Berto has not been tested so he may fold under pressure.

[Fox McCloud]

In the rankings I would go with Joshua Clotty because of who he fought and how he performed against top competition{Margarito,Mayweather,Judah}but in terms of overall skill I would pick Berto.The problem is Berto has not been tested so he may fold under pressure.

??????????????????

[TheManchine]

Clottey,

Berto has the potential, he just needs to step up in competition and prove himself as a top ww,

if they fought now, i think Clottey would win

[slicksouthpaw16]

Clottey simply becuase he is the all around better fighter and is tested against the elite. Berto needs to fight someone with a pulse becuase i am not quite sold on him yet.

[K-Nan]

Andre Berto definitely has more upside to his career. I think Clottey is at his best so currently I rank him higher, but Berto will probably surpass him.

[The Texican]

I'm taking Berto in this one. Don't get me wrong, Clottey is a tuff SOB can give most top fighters problems all night. But I feel that Andre Berto would simply outclass him. The differences in talent would be on full display if they ever fought. Speed kills.

[Bad-Wlad]

Clottey simply becuase he is the all around better fighter and is tested against the elite. Berto needs to fight someone with a pulse becuase i am not quite sold on him yet.

i echo this post

Berto has beat David Estrada and that is his best win

Clottey has fought guys like Judah ,Margarito ,Baldomir ,Corrales ,Gutierrez

[ALT-Assassin]

??????????????????

My bad,I don't know what I was thinking.