Dave Tiberi definetly beat James Toney IMO

[Dynamite Kid]

From what I hear this should have been the case. I still havent seen the fight yet. I'm curious to see how out of shape James really was.

I guess this makes up for the second Griffin fight and the first Peter fight.

Toney was well out of shape he was blowing after 1 round he was struggling with weight and was unerconditioned

[Slotff]

...and Toney went the distance, Cotto just got his ass demolished by a can that cant move his head 2 inches in either direction to miss a punch. Whats your point?

This was never about Cotto or Margarito, and it certainly did not seem to be some kind of attack. Why can there never be reasonable talks on these boards?

[DiegoFuego]

I need to score this one again, but what other gifts are you referring to in Toney's case? The only other fight I can remember thinking he may have deserved to lose was the Reggie Johnson fight, which was close as hell but definitely not clear one way or the other.

Plus throw in that he got robbed against Peter in the first fight and a lot of people had him beating Griffin both times as well. He's been robbed more than he's gotten gifts if you ask most people.

[Dynamite Kid]

I need to score this one again, but what other gifts are you referring to in Toney's case? The only other fight I can remember thinking he may have deserved to lose was the Reggie Johnson fight, which was close as hell but definitely not clear one way or the other.

Plus throw in that he got robbed against Peter in the first fight and a lot of people had him beating Griffin both times as well. He's been robbed more than he's gotten gifts if you ask most people.

he did not beat McCallum

im sick of people saying he was robbed against Peter was he **** that was damn close fight and very hard to score it was not a clear decision for either fighter

i had him beating Reggie Johnson by about 2 rounds maybe 3 Johnson started well and scored a knockdown but he faded big time a Toney took over the rest of the fight