If Katsidis can cut Diaz, Katsidis wins

[badboypeenoy]

Power - goes to Katisidis
Speed - basically the same
Relentlessness - basically the same
Skills - Diaz edges Katsidis
Chin - Diaz has the edge as Katsidis has been down before
Heart - Katsidis edges Diaz because Diaz practically mellows down when cut
and Katsidis has the tools to cut Diaz

I don't think Diaz' power can deter Katsidis but I think Diaz would succumb to another Nate Campbell like pressure fighter. Whoever fights backpedaling would lose this one...of course I'm a newbie so this analysis wouldn't really have weight. Still I'd go for Katsidis.

[Mr. Ryan]

I think one attribute you omitted was punch output, and that would go to Diaz. Diaz has the ability to just let his hands go and you can never underestimate that, especially with someone who is hard to miss like Katsidis.

[Texanballer]

I think Katsidis can throw a lot of punches when a lot arent coming back

Juan Diaz is gonna throw 120 punches a round when he wants to.

[Blue Öyster]

katsidis and diaz are both overrated!!! but katsidis is a complete and total bum!!!

diaz will beat him up easily!!!

[Gareth Ivanovic]

Should be interesting if Diaz does get cut again, because he didn't react to well when if happend against Campbell. I think he learned from that experience and will be able to outwork Katsidis and either win on cuts or a decision.

[Zocalo]

You fail to take into consideration that Katsidis is more likely to get cut. Think you underrate the value of Daiz/Katsidis chin. I think that will be the difference. One can take the shots, the other cant.

[My Name Is...]

I'll bet 20K on Diaz.....
I have never been more sure of a fight in my life!!

[Zerwas1]

Defense goes to Diaz and Katsidis cuts earlier, Diaz by a landslide

[My Name Is...]

katsidis and diaz are both overrated!!! but katsidis is a complete and total bum!!!

diaz will beat him up easily!!!

How was Diaz over rated.....

Almost unified the division... Remember PW had a bad night, I guess he was over rated too. Diaz will beat CAmpbell if they fight again, Casamayor, and break down Guzman running ass. Guz better have his track shoes on. That boys runs, runs, runs, and runs some more. He will get chopped down like Cotto.

[MANGLER]

I say Diaz wins this one.