Calzaghe is an overrated bum....

[Dan...]

It's hard to put Cotto over Margarito when he just lost to him in the same weight class. Cotto has more skills but Tony still won convincingly at the end of the day.

I rank Winky that high since he's proved time and again that he can compete against bigger and stronger fighters coming up from a lighter weight. Winky still would beat most fighters from WW-LHW, which is pretty impressive considering his size and lack of power. Most top fighters who have something to lose wont give Winky a fight for a reason.

I like Winky I just don't think he has the wins to back up top 10 p4p right now.

Also, could you please provide me with a reasonable explanation for Ricky being 3 on your list?

[Johnny Rebel]

I heard you were delusional but that is ridiculous, Hatton at 3?

An argument can be made to knock off any of the P4P fighters since they all have losses except Calzaghe and Pavlik. Why should Hatton drop out of the top 10 when his only loss is when he moved up in weight to fight the P4P #1 at the time (Floyd Mayweather) when other fighters lose to much lesser fighters and don't get dropped?

[Johnny Rebel]

I like Winky I just don't think he has the wins to back up top 10 p4p right now.

Also, could you please provide me with a reasonable explanation for Ricky being 3 on your list?

Hatton beat the #2 P4P fighter (Kostya Tszyu) and then went on to win a title in a 2nd weight division over Collazo. Hatton has also beaten 8 World Champions and is still unbeaten at JWW.

[Dan...]

An argument can be made to knock off any of the P4P fighters since they all have losses except Calzaghe and Pavlik. Why should Hatton drop out of the top 10 when his only loss is when he moved up in weight to fight the P4P #1 at the time (Floyd Mayweather) when other fighters lose to much lesser fighters and don't get dropped?

He doesn't have the wins the be on there. He looked terrible last time out and got KTFO in the fight prior. His only really good win was against Kostya and that was years ago.