Who was the better fighter overall: Floyd Mayweather vs Joe Calzaghe

[Scott9945]

Conquer, JC#1, Joe2608, Johnny Rebel, majestiC, QuCongee, theghost#1, Tunney

Can you give me some reason in why he is better and how???

Right there is your hidden agenda. It couldn't be any clearer. But I'm not going to play your game and spell it out for you. What will tomorrows poll be, Ricky Hatton vs Tommy Hearns or Greg Haugen vs Aaron Pryor?

[Flawless]

Right there is your hidden agenda. It couldn't be any clearer. But I'm not going to play your game and spell it out for you. What will tomorrows poll be, Ricky Hatton vs Tommy Hearns or Greg Haugen vs Aaron Pryor?

WTF, are you alright mate. They voted for Calzaghe and they must have a reason to it. Everyone has an opinion and they are entitled to it. This is a forum no one is right or wrong when comparing careers. I was just wondering why they thought Calzaghe without posting a reply.

People who voted for Calzaghe can you please drop in a comment to why you voted Calzaghe.

[QuCongee]

Conquer, JC#1, Joe2608, Johnny Rebel, majestiC, QuCongee, theghost#1, Tunney

Can you give me some reason in why he is better and how???

Wtf. How many different ways can I say what I already said?

[Flawless]

Wtf. How many different ways can I say what I already said?

Why is Calzaghe better?
Is his resume better do you think??
Is he naturally the better fighter??
Do his achievements overshadow Mayweather’s???
What attributes does Calzaghe have that Mayweather doesn’t??

Answer these questions, on why you voted Calzaghe.

[OTSS]

Why is Calzaghe better?
Is his resume better do you think??
Is he naturally the better fighter??
Do his achievements overshadow Mayweather’s???
What attributes does Calzaghe have that Mayweather doesn’t??

Answer these questions, on why you voted Calzaghe.

You're not King are you?

[MANGLER]

Who was the better fighter overall: Floyd Mayweather vs Joe Calzaghe


Let's take everything into account.
Resume
Who was the better boxer
Achievements
Records


Discuss

[Resume - PBF. Joe C's only beaten name fighters in the last 2 years.
Who was the better boxer - PBF. Joe C is more excitin to watch but PBF is more complete.
Achievements - PBF. Had more meaningful fights, won more titles, even tho Joe C held his much longer.
Records - PBF. He took some risks early in his career that Joe C didn't.

[QuCongee]

Why is Calzaghe better?
Is his resume better do you think??
Is he naturally the better fighter??
Do his achievements overshadow Mayweather’s???
What attributes does Calzaghe have that Mayweather doesn’t??

Answer these questions, on why you voted Calzaghe.

Wtf. I tried to go back and quote your original question so I could explain further why I voted for Calzaghe. You edited the original question.

You had PPV sales as a critera and my reaction was based heavily on that. Now you want me to defend my position? You changed the question after I answered it.

[Flawless]

Too narrow a question. Of course Floyd is more complete.

Then why did you vote Calzaghe

[ippo]

How can you even compare joe to Floyd, Floyd is miles ahead of joe.

[QuCongee]

Then why did you vote Calzaghe

Because the original question (not the now edited version) was heavily biased in Floyd's favor, suggesting that PPV sales should be considered.

The new question (the one I did'nt answer) does'nt mention PPV sales and that's completely different.

If you are now asking me to just chose based on all-around skill then I pick Floyd. But when you said PPV sales should make a difference, of course I called bull**** and voted the other way.

Why else would you have changed the question? I can't re-vote, so don't change a question after it's already been answered.