Who was the better fighter overall: Floyd Mayweather vs Joe Calzaghe

[streak12]

Mayweather def

[Jose Rizal]

Floyd easy.

I know it sounds crazy, but with Floyd weighing at about 150 and Joe at light heavyweight, I'd still pick Floyd to outbox Old Joe in that fantasy fight and decision him...hehe. That's how highly I regard Floyd's boxing brain, his skills and his conditioning, and I'm sure he'll know the solution to those slaps that has eluded both Old Roy and Old Bhop.

[SkilledB]

That's not fair either cause bigger guys have a harder time moving up. What's Calzaghe supposed to do? Fight Haye and Klitschko?

i dont think Roy Jones had a Problem moving from MW to HW to be Ruiz eh?


if your bigger your body is made to carry more, your body is more adapt to be used to carry more weight.

comming from a guy who weigh's 135 right now, and has been to 147,154, its rough to move up like that

[StarshipTrooper]

Floyd easy.

I know it sounds crazy, but with Floyd weighing at about 150 and Joe at light heavyweight, I'd still pick Floyd to outbox Old Joe in that fantasy fight and decision him...hehe. That's how highly I regard Floyd's boxing brain, his skills and his conditioning, and I'm sure he'll know the solution to those slaps that has eluded both Old Roy and Old Bhop.

You think maybe he'll put his track shoes on and run like a punk ***** the way he did against De La Hoya?

Poet

[StarshipTrooper]

For the final time. Calzaghe is a nobody compared to Mayweather. Mayweather has beaten more quality oppenents and recognizable names.

Like who in their primes?

Held more titles in more divisions.

A meaningless accolade just as it was when Hearns and Leonard where belt collecting, especially considering all the bogus weight classes and title belts that are phonier than 3 dollar bills.

Is faster, damn near impossible to hit, and is a defensive genius.

He runs like a hubcap stealing punk with the cops after him.

And he did it all in less than half the time it took Joe.

Did what? Since when is premature ejacualtion something to boast about?

Poet