Would Margarito have lost to Carlos Quintana??!?!

[boxer12]

No, Quintana doesn't beat Margarito because all he did to beat Williams was box and move. The same way Cotto tried to beat Margarito, but failed. Plus, Quintana doesn't have enough firepower to keep Tony off him. One more thing, Margarito didn't lose to Williams, he just ran out of rounds. I seem to remember how strong Tony was coming on late in the fight. He just waited too long to make his move.

that is the ******est thing ive seen on this forum.

he ran...out...of...rounds

woooooooooooooooooooooooooooow

[The Texican]

OK, maybe I should have left that part out. Haha. But I do remember Williams looking beat up and not a scratch on Tony. But points are points. It's not like Williams dominated Margarito, and it's not like he could easily beat him again.

[bsrizpac]

The quintana who fought Williams and won!??

My answer is no....

Therefore.....

How can you put Paul Williams ahead of Antonio Margarito if he lost to a guy Margarito would have beaten twice?

also....

We all know if Margarito showed up against Williams in their fight that Margarito would have won.

So discuss

Jesus christ shut the **** up. What would he have used? His stellar marg defense of blocking punches with his face? Quintana was boxing well on the outside and STAYED boxing the whole time (aka didn't stay on the ropes against Paul or engage on the inside). Marga**** would have lost that fight.

As for "that margarito showed up" bull****: coulda woulda shoulda. ****ing Margarine fans have more excuses than any other fighter in history.