What if - IF - Mayweather comes back and beats Margarito....?

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Is he then on your shortlist for GOAT? Do you then rank him among the Leonards, Durans, Whitakers, etc

[Texanballer]

It depends on how he beats him.

If its like he beat hatton yes, if its how he beat Baldomir then no

[fightingfigs]

NO he will be great and I will forever not doubt him

[fightingfigs]

Doesnt matter how he wins becaus ethe only way he will win is by decision

[Addition]

It depends on how he beats him.

If its like he beat hatton yes, if its how he beat Baldomir then no

Erm you know as well as I do that Mayweather isn't knocking out Marg.

A well earned UD is good enough.

[El Dominicano]

Is he then on your shortlist for GOAT? Do you then rank him among the Leonards, Durans, Whitakers, etc

No! because that is an easy task.

[pesticid]

Is he then on your shortlist for GOAT? Do you then rank him among the Leonards, Durans, Whitakers, etc

He isn't coming back and fighting Tony. He may be itching, but he doesn't have the courage. Even if you give him 100 mil, which is supposedly the amount that would get him out of retirement. Hello, that ****er made only 15-20 mill against DLH.

[Haterfree]

The haters would claim that Margarito was a bum & that Floyd is scared senseless of fighting Paul Williams. The Mexicans would chant bull**** after the fight no matter how obvious the victory is.

[Check]

I wouldnt put him on the shortlist(if thats like top 10) but I would move him way up maybe top 20. I still think floyd has to beat the champ at 147 and maybe cotto or williams. Maybe beat a pacquaio too. If he did that he would be top 10.

[RightHandLead]

It's entirely possible. But Floyd would win on points because he can't knock Margarito out. So right now, people will say "yeah, GOAT" whatever, and then as soon as it happens it will turn into "PBF ran" and all that other typical ****.

He can't win even when he wins, and he won't be respected until he's long gone. Hopkins is having a similar issue as of late. I remember when he beat Tarver and retired, all the appreciation threads, everybody was loving him. Then he came back and I'm one of his very few supporters on here who still think he's an all time great.