Who's the best Welterweight?

[RightHandLead]

Last night's fight was amazing and I was very happy to see Margarito get his biggest career win, but it didn't really solve anything in terms of defining who the best Welterweight. Check out the latest Ring Magazine rankings for the Welterweight division. (As of July 20th)

1.) Miguel Cotto - Beat Quintana, Judah, Mosley and Gomez. Beaten by Margarito.

2.) Shane Mosley - Beat De La Hoya, lost to Forrest, lost to Wright, beat Vargas, lost to Cotto.

3.) Paul Williams - Beat Margarito, lost to Quintana, beat Quintana.

4.) Antonio Margarito - Beat Clottey, beat Cintron, lost to Williams, beat Cintron again, beat Cotto.

5.) Carlos Quintana - Beat Julio, lost to Cotto, beat Williams, lost to Williams.

6.) Zab Judah - Lost to Spinks, beat Spinks, lost to Baldomir, lost to Mayweather, lost to Cotto.

7.) Joshua Clottey - Lost to Margarito, beat Corrales.

8.) Luis Collazo - Lost to Hatton, lost to Mosley.

9.) Jackson Bonsu - No noteworthy opponets.

10.) Andre Berto - Beat Rivera, beat Estrada, beat Rodriguez.

The top 7 guys all have traded losses amongst each other. Clottey lost to Margarito, who lost to Williams, who lost to Quintana, who lost to Cotto, who lost to Margarito. It goes on and on.

So who is the best in your opinion?

[larryx]

Last night's fight was amazing and I was very happy to see Margarito get his biggest career win, but it didn't really solve anything in terms of defining who the best Welterweight. Check out the latest Ring Magazine rankings for the Welterweight division. (As of July 20th)

1.) Miguel Cotto - Beat Quintana, Judah, Mosley and Gomez. Beaten by Margarito.

2.) Shane Mosley - Beat De La Hoya, lost to Forrest, lost to Wright, beat Vargas, lost to Cotto.

3.) Paul Williams - Beat Margarito, lost to Quintana, beat Quintana.

4.) Antonio Margarito - Beat Clottey, beat Cintron, lost to Williams, beat Cintron again, beat Cotto.

5.) Carlos Quintana - Beat Julio, lost to Cotto, beat Williams, lost to Williams.

6.) Zab Judah - Lost to Spinks, beat Spinks, lost to Baldomir, lost to Mayweather, lost to Cotto.

7.) Joshua Clottey - Lost to Margarito, beat Corrales.

8.) Luis Collazo - Lost to Hatton, lost to Mosley.

9.) Jackson Bonsu - No noteworthy opponets.

10.) Andre Berto - Beat Rivera, beat Estrada, beat Rodriguez.

The top 7 guys all have traded losses amongst each other. Clottey lost to Margarito, who lost to Williams, who lost to Quintana, who lost to Cotto, who lost to Margarito. It goes on and on.

So who is the best in your opinion?

berto should be at 6,judah shouldnt even be in the top 10 he hasnt won a significant fight in 4 years and who is bonsu?

[larryx]

and mosley#2 please
1 margo
2 cotto
3 williams
4 mosley
5 berto
6 quintana
and the rest

the champion -vacated by money may

[RightHandLead]

and mosley#2 please
1 margo
2 cotto
3 williams
4 mosley
5 berto
6 quintana
and the rest

the champion -vacated by money may

Well this is Ring Magazine we're talking about. Shane at #2 is not surprising considering Oscar owns the company.

And Judah on there is out of place IMO, and I love Zab. But the dude has lost every big fight he's ever been in and hasn't looked good since Tszyu drilled him in the second round.

[RightHandLead]

berto should be at 6,judah shouldnt even be in the top 10 he hasnt won a significant fight in 4 years and who is bonsu?

I agree about Judah, unless he beats Clottey. Then I think he gets a spot on there somewhere.

And I have no idea who the **** Bonsu is.

[MANGLER]

Tony is the boss right now, but he can't hold onto that claim for long without fightin Williams.

[El Dominicano]

Last night's fight was amazing and I was very happy to see Margarito get his biggest career win, but it didn't really solve anything in terms of defining who the best Welterweight. Check out the latest Ring Magazine rankings for the Welterweight division. (As of July 20th)

1.) Miguel Cotto - Beat Quintana, Judah, Mosley and Gomez. Beaten by Margarito.

2.) Shane Mosley - Beat De La Hoya, lost to Forrest, lost to Wright, beat Vargas, lost to Cotto.

3.) Paul Williams - Beat Margarito, lost to Quintana, beat Quintana.

4.) Antonio Margarito - Beat Clottey, beat Cintron, lost to Williams, beat Cintron again, beat Cotto.

5.) Carlos Quintana - Beat Julio, lost to Cotto, beat Williams, lost to Williams.

6.) Zab Judah - Lost to Spinks, beat Spinks, lost to Baldomir, lost to Mayweather, lost to Cotto.

7.) Joshua Clottey - Lost to Margarito, beat Corrales.

8.) Luis Collazo - Lost to Hatton, lost to Mosley.

9.) Jackson Bonsu - No noteworthy opponets.

10.) Andre Berto - Beat Rivera, beat Estrada, beat Rodriguez.

The top 7 guys all have traded losses amongst each other. Clottey lost to Margarito, who lost to Williams, who lost to Quintana, who lost to Cotto, who lost to Margarito. It goes on and on.

So who is the best in your opinion?

Pual beat Quintana 2nd time. This make Pual the best WW so far

[RightHandLead]

Pual beat Quintana 2nd time. This make Pual the best WW so far

I didn't neglect to mention that Paul beat Carlos the second time out.

And isn't Williams supposed to fight Wright next at 154?