more respectable win Oscar over Pac or Calz over Jones ?

[abadger]

If Pac beat Oscar that would be pretty amazing considering the size differerence, and the fact that Oscar is actually still a good boxer. Jones is shot, so its an easy question for me to answer.

OOPS: Wrong way round. If Oscar beats Pac thats probably worse than Calzaghe beating Jones, Oscar may still be the best at 154 and beating up a guy 3 weight classes below you is a little harsh.

[Live Dog]

Oscar over Pac. I'll take a win over the P4P #1 over a win against an aged champion regardless of weight concerns.

[MELLY-MEL...]

Calzaghe over Jones, at least it's not a physical mismatch.

agreed..................

[JOM'S]

i think these question should be revised...

GREATER WIN/IMPACT ON BOXING

PAC over Oscar or Jones over Calz ?