Roy Jones Jr (2003 vs Ruiz) vs James Toney (2003 vs Jirov) @ Cruiserweight.

[HomeBoys]

Both weighed around 200 lbs, who you got and why?

Don't give me the old **** "Roy already beat him" HE BEAT A WEIGHT DRAINED VERSION. Apparently Roy can only be weight drained when he loses and no one else.

[Ryn0]

Roy Jones.....

[RagingBull22]

Toney would've knocked Jones out cold

[Darkstar]

James Toney without a doubt. It would have took nothing short of a court order to ever get RJJ back in the ring with Toney. RJJs win over Ruiz is overrated, Toney beat him too.

[Dan...]

Roy beats that version of James fairly easily. Just way too much speed. Roy UD. I am a big James fan and he would definatley have given Roy a lot of trouble at times in his career, but at this point I would have picked Roy.

[MANGLER]

Roy. He's better than Toney. Period.

[-Antonio-]

Roy Jones always beats Toney, even when he's at his best. It'd be better contested.

[pesticid]

Roy is just a terrible match-up for Toney.

[Kball15]

I think its definetly a more competitive fight, but You still gotta pick JONES JR by Clear decision

[Brunswick Assassin]

Toney would have made Jones have convulsions whilst lying on the canvas. Roy's **** scared to fight James given Toney's been calling out Roy for last 13 years. Didn't Roy say that he'd fight James again guaranteed if he won the Cruiserweight Title???? Roy was even meant to fight Jirov insisting he weighed at 190lb which never materialised. Jones even insisted Merqui Sosa and Sugarboy Malinga come in well under their normanl fighting weights. What does that tell you about Roy?