If Juan Diaz beats Katsidis Easier than Casamayor did...

[Texanballer]

Would you put him ahead of Casamayor p4p ranking wise in the lightweight division?

[warp1432]

No. Casamayor is still the champ of the division and so he should be rated #1.

Though if you want to talk about who's best:

Pacquiao > Casamayor > Campbell > Diaz >> the rest

[rj_ct]

p4p ranking wise in the lightweight division?

what does that even mean? i hate the idea of "pound for pound" as it is.

anyway, juan is the man and one of my favorite fighters to watch, but you can't you use the triangle theory in boxing (or really any sport for that matter).

[Mr. Ryan]

It doesn't matter really, who knows how much Katsidis has left after the poundings he has taken in his last two fights? The only way I'd move Juan Diaz ahead of Casamayor is if he beats him or Casamayor loses. Other than that, a fight with Katsidis really doesn't prove much, it's just a good entertaining scrap on paper.

[Texanballer]

I think id put campbell over casamayor.

[Texanballer]

Bumppp!!!!!!!!!!!

[warp1432]

Like I said already. Casamayor's victory was more impressive to me.

[Avenue]

no
casamayor would kill Diaz
and im a big diaz fan

[Pico Hollywood]

Bumppp!!!!!!!!!!!

So if Guzman beats campbell would you have him over casa too?

[jdubb863]

No. Casamayor is still the champ of the division and so he should be rated #1.

Though if you want to talk about who's best:

Pacquiao > Casamayor > Campbell > Diaz >> the rest

How do you have Pacquiao ahead? cuase he beat david diaz? the most vulnarble man in lightweight, with no speed power or skill just toughness?... In that case if marquez beats Casa or guzman beats nate, Pacquiao should go to the bottom of the list cuase casa is 1 lightweight and nate has 3 belts. Way more competitive fights.