Top 50 GOAT

[black.ink]

Ali Top 3 at least

Apart from SRR, who else would you put above Ali?

[THE REED]

Apart from SRR, who else would you put above Ali?

henry armstrong........

[black.ink]

henry armstrong........

I have Henry at 3. I just don't see anybody but SRR above Ali.

[THE REED]

I have Henry at 3. I just don't see anybody but SRR above Ali.

i think holding 3 weight class titles all at the same time, and losing a controversial fourth weightclass is PRETTY hard to beat

[FUC_U_PAYME]

I have Henry at 3. I just don't see anybody but SRR above Ali.

i got Herny at # 2 but can see why some would put Ali at 2

[mexicomanda1]

pretty good list! but...

RATED TOO HIGH:

joe frazier - great heavyweight but not this high. maybe in the 40's.
marcel cerdan - waaaaay to high!
jake la motta - great fighter but shouldn't even be on this list.

RATED TOO LOW:
marvin hagler - one of top 3 greatest middles of all time.
bernard hopkins - top 5 middles of all time.
roy jones jr. - rated way too low.

TOO EARLY TO TELL:
joe calzaghe - hasn't done enough to warrant this high.

DEFINITELY DESERVES TO BE ON LIST:
wilfredo gomez - greatest jr. featherweight of all-time. title fights 18-0 18 KO's
salvador sanchez - probably not on this list because he died so young.
lennox lewis - probably one of top 5-6 heavies of all time.

SHOULD BE STRONGLY CONSIDERED:
carlos zarate - 66-4 63 KO's. probably greatest puncher in bantam history.
ricardo lopez - 51-0-1 38 KO's w/24 title defenses.
pancho villa - another one who died too young to have strong consideration.