Difficult Scenario For Calzaghe Haters

[Felixion]

If Joe Calzaghe beats Roy Jones Jr. on Sept. 20th, then proceeds to beat Kelly Pavlik @ 168, would you then concede that he is a great fighter?

[Sir_Joe]

He already is. He will become the best fighter of this era if he wins on the 20th though.

[Blue Öyster]

fightin "old man jones" is a complete waste of time! joe should fight pavlik sooner rather than later!! pavlik isn't as great as people seem to think he is and joe more than has a chance of beating him, but time is not on calzaghes side.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Pavlik will become "overhyped and overrated" after Joe beats him.

[realheavyhands]

i feel sorry for calzaghe fans that actually think he was a shot vs roy jones... theres no way calzaghe can beat roy jones unless he was in whales...calzaghe has no idea what he getting him self into... roy might be just another man..but hes a master..

[poeticlsykuac]

He already is. He will become the best fighter of this era if he wins on the 20th though.

Of his era?

Lets see, Mayweather, DLH, Trinidad, Hop, Jones, Lewis, Pacman, Morales, Barrera, Tszyu, etc. He really doesn't seem to have a bigger legacy then anyone of those fighters who all fought during his era.

[johnm is...]

i feel sorry for calzaghe fans that actually think he was a shot vs roy jones... theres no way calzaghe can beat roy jones unless he was in whales...calzaghe has no idea what he getting him self into... roy might be just another man..but hes a master..

Well, I think one thing's for sure. If Calzaghe does beat RJJ, this will be one of the most "sig'd" quotes of all time.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

i feel sorry for calzaghe fans that actually think he was a shot vs roy jones... theres no way calzaghe can beat roy jones unless he was in whales...calzaghe has no idea what he getting him self into... roy might be just another man..but hes a master..

Jaws, Willy or Flipper?

[Ryn0]

i feel sorry for calzaghe fans that actually think he was a shot vs roy jones... theres no way calzaghe can beat roy jones unless he was in whales...calzaghe has no idea what he getting him self into... roy might be just another man..but hes a master..

An old master..... Calzaghe is fighting a shot fighter for money. Would you like to bet on Jones?

[2quick2slick]

If Joe Calzaghe beats Roy Jones Jr. on Sept. 20th, then proceeds to beat Kelly Pavlik @ 168, would you then concede that he is a great fighter?

Yes I would.