Should Roy Jones beat Calzaghe, Shoud he?

[Easy-E]

Retire.
He should be retired right now if you ask me.

[Speecha]

I think he should retire because beatin joe will almost nulify his losses to tarver and johnson because he would be beating one of the top p4p right now..but i can't see him retiring if he wins because temptation will be too much for him...he could beat samuel peter with relative ease and i think he knows that, there's too many options there 4 him..the johnson or tarver rematch may lure him..especially if one of them calls out his name

[moofo]

A. Retire
B. Give Joe a Rematch
C. Give Bernard Hopkins a Rematch
D. Give James Toney a Rematch
E. Try to even the score with Glen Johnson
F. Try to even the score with Tarver
G. Set his sights on 2 more fights- Johnson AND Tarver to Even the Scores
H. Seek out Chad Dawson
I. Move To Middleweight to Challenge Pavlik
J. Move to Heavyweight to Challenge Sam Peter

I, for one, am torn between A. and G. myself....

Roy won't win...END OF THREAD.

[The Surgeon]

I got Roy to beat Joe and after that id like him to retire but another Tarver Fight would be good for him because he CAN beat that guy especially with high confidence after a Tito and Zag double win! GJ im not so sure if he could beat that type of fighter at this point

[MWMerlino]

After seeing what Johnson did to Dawson I would have to say RETIRE.

[BigDog9]

i say roy beats the crap out of him rematch to do it again then retire.