Does Zab Judah deserve a rematch with Cotto?

[Guest]

what cost judah the fight was his weak mentality when he gets pressured.

he just can't handle pressure.

he couldn't handle powerless Baldomirs pressure.

Watch the fight before you say that. Zab won that fight by a clear 4 rounds.

[mspiegelo]

Man, you are ignorant as hell kid. Judah has only koed one person in 147 and it was a completely unknown person and you think he was going to ko Cotto that has only been down once in his entire career in one round?

umm he stopped 3 people at welterweight (technically 4 cause that no contest against ruben galvan was bull****) and one of the was cory spinks for all the belts!!! i think he was someone!

[Pugilistic™]

Watch the fight before you say that. Zab won that fight by a clear 4 rounds.

how come no one else has said that fight was a robbery but you.

[mspiegelo]

Watch the fight before you say that. Zab won that fight by a clear 4 rounds.

true. a horrible decision, but judah did have a few awful rounds. jesus.

[Scott9945]

Man, you are ignorant as hell kid. Judah has only koed one person in 147 and it was a completely unknown person and you think he was going to ko Cotto that has only been down once in his entire career in one round?

I don't usually come to the defense of Zab Judah, but I wouldn't describe Cory Spinks as a completely unknown person.

[120]

umm he stopped 3 people at welterweight (technically 4 cause that no contest against ruben galvan was bull****) and one of the was cory spinks for all the belts!!! i think he was someone!

my apologies, i meant in the first round, not overall.

[120]

I don't usually come to the defense of Zab Judah, but I wouldn't describe Cory Spinks as a completely unknown person.

again sorry, i meant in the first. The argument was that if it wasn't for the low-blow, Zab would've koed cotto in the first.

[-Swizzy-]

I've heard a few people arguing this point. How does the forum feel?

nope. it wasn't like their fight was a close split decision. if judah wants a rematch, he should work his way back up the welterweight ladder but I doubt he is capable(mentally) of doing that.

[IMDAZED]

Zab doesn't even deserve the title shot he's getting, how the **** could he possibly deserve a rematch with Cotto? When's the last time Zab beat a top 20 fighter?

[Shalafi]

Why? Cotto dominated Zab and ****ed him up, the only thing cheap about the fight were the two obvious low blows from Cotto and some roughing but it's part of boxing. I really don't think a second fight would be any different than the first, besides Judah keeps getting chance after chance and he always blows each of them.