Better Resume Joan Guzman or Juan Diaz??

[Texanballer]

Joan Guzman Notable Wins
Humberto Soto 43-5-2 UD 12
Jorge Barrios SD 46-2-1 12
Fernando Beltran Jr 18-0-0 UD 12
Terdsak Jandaeng 24-0-1 UD 12


Juan Diaz Notable Wins
Julio Diaz 34-3-0 TKO 9
Acelino Freitas 38-1-0 TKO 8
Jose Miguel Cotto 27-0-0 UD 12
Julien Lorcy 56-3-2 UD 12

Juan Diaz Notable Loss
Nate Campbell 31-5-1 SD 12

[Boxingfan81]

Not even close, Juan Diaz has the much better resume, how bout posting the past 6 or 7 fights, not just 4.

[warp1432]

Pretty close, but Joan Guzman takes it.

[RAESAAD]

I say Diaz and personally don't consider it very close.....

[loui_ludwig]

I go with Joan Guzman. Won belts in diffirent weight divisions, better boxing skills.

[DiegoFuego]

Freitas is the best win between them. Guzman has only fought two good fighters and neither is a great fighter. Freitas at one time was considered great.

[GTL]

Ill say Diaz, even tho Guzman is the better man..

[Michelle21]

Joan Guzman....

[Jim Jeffries]

I go with Joan Guzman. Won belts in diffirent weight divisions, better boxing skills.

I think winning 3 belts in one division is more impressive than winning the WBO (the weakest of the three) in two divisions. And this thread's not about boxing skills, it's about resumes.

[Mr. Ryan]

Freitas is the best win between them. Guzman has only fought two good fighters and neither is a great fighter. Freitas at one time was considered great.

I don't know many people who would consider Freitas great. His best wins were a very close decision over Casamayor, Jorge Barrios and Artur Grigorian. Freitas' resume is among the most padded of records.

A "great" resume' would be something like Wilfredo Benitez's wins over Duran, Carlos Palomino and Antonio Cervantes.

Freitas was good, but I wouldn't say great.