Pound for Pound: Who makes it out, Undefeated?!

[The_Italian]

All fighters Prime for Prime... and all fights pound for Pound
(Meaning Power is equal among all fighters)

In other words, who could beat more fighters, pound for pound, than anyone else...

If it helps you almost imagine as if they were sparring... who would get the better of it...

Im going to say Ali.

To make a long story short i believe ali overall (ie. in all areas) is the most balanced fighter of the group.

Floyd can only box...he's not an inside fighter to say the least...

guys like tyson do all their damage on the inside...

I think if ali didnt make it all the way he'd come close. He was a genius on the outside and could hold his own on the inside...the other major advantage he would have is that he was/is one of the smartest fighters to ever step into a professional boxing ring hands down, top 5 at the VERY LEAST.

i think that combination should be enough to either take him all the way or come REAL close...

[Sweet Pea 50]

Beating Roger "Black Mamba" Mayweather having a padded record?? Please...Floyd couldnt beat the man that gave him the blueprints for his success in his wildest dreams let alone chavez.

Nope.
Floyd was a different beast at 135. I'd put him up there against ANYBODY at that weight.
Duran, Pea, all the greats.
Mayweather was that good at that weight.

[Dan...]

Roy Jones Jr.

Totally dominant in his prime. Never seen anyone completely dominate quality opposition like he did for so many years. Just too much talent to be beaten.

[shadeyfizzle]

Nope.
Floyd was a different beast at 135. I'd put him up there against ANYBODY at that weight.
Duran, Pea, all the greats.
Mayweather was that good at that weight.

I dont see it. Im a bigger roger mayweather fan than a floyd fan. I dont think lil floyd could beat uncle roger prime for prime.

[J_CON]

Pound for pound, Robinson.

.....agreed...

[J_CON]

I dont see it. Im a bigger roger mayweather fan than a floyd fan. I dont think lil floyd could beat uncle roger prime for prime.

lol....your joking right?

[shadeyfizzle]

lol....your joking right?

No im not. If they fought prime 4 prime then roger never trained floyd. floyd wouldnt be **** without uncle roger, the same way tyson wasnt **** without d'amato in the corner.

[the_godslayer]

people are forgetting a major name here ..... Marvelous Marvin Hagler .... he HAS to be up there in the all time P4P lists .... just IMO of course as he is one of my fave fighters of all time and seriously underrated.

[aussieboxer2320]

robinson kills em all prime for prime man

he was the best , simply the best ever

[slicksouthpaw16]

Hagler would have been a good option of he was on the list but i would go with Ali. He was unbeaten when he was in his prime and has the best resume at heavyweight. Most of his greatest wins came after he was released from prison so he was past his true prime. Peak Ali has more footspeed and his reflexes was a lot better, he would have won those fights against Norton and Frazier more convincingly. He was the best and most skilled heavyweight and i honestly can't see anyone beating him in his prime.