More Impressive/Significant Victory: Mayweather/Gatti or Pavlik/Lockett

[MikeBrew328]

Well most likely Kelly Pavlik will get moved into the P4P #1 spot in my eyes, I mean how could he not looking at the fighters he's fought, he's still undefeated and doesn't look like anybody will beat him.

Mayweather had a similar situation with Jones falling off the top spot when he fought Gatti a big puncher but heavy underdog.

[NeXt In Line]

No contest Mayweather-Gatti was the more impressive victory. Speed, power, combinations landing flush, just overall such a DOMINANT performance. Pavlik/Lockett was one-sided, Mayweather-Gatti was DOMINANCE.

And there's no way Pavlik is P4P #1, he hasn't fought enough good/great fighters yet, his two biggest wins are Jermain Taylor and Edison Miranda.

[Kball15]

Gatti is a better fighter then Lockett imo, definetly tougher even though Lockett seemed tough, and mayweather beat the living **** outta him.

And Pavlik shouldn't move up even a spot after tonight. He didnt beat anybody worthy of something like that. If he beats Calzaghe, THEN i think a p4p #1 spot would be waranted, depending on how he won.

[MikeBrew328]

No contest Mayweather-Gatti was the more impressive victory. Speed, power, combinations landing flush, just overall such a DOMINANT performance. Pavlik/Lockett was one-sided, Mayweather-Gatti was DOMINANCE.

And there's no way Pavlik is P4P #1, he hasn't fought enough good/great fighters yet, his two biggest wins are Jermain Taylor and Edison Miranda.

Who would you give it to then?

And wouldn't a one sided fight be dominance????

[MWMerlino]

Anyone who gives credit to Money for beating up a brain dead Gatti is smoking sherm...honestly.

****ing Gomez dominated Gatti. The man should've stopped boxing along with Ward instead of taking 10 years off of his life to continue pleasing the over sized bar room that is his New Jersey fan base.

And on the other hand you have Pavlik dominating every opponent he has ever faced, none of which stepped into the ring with their frontal lobe suffering from complete erosion.

[Burner]

Pavlik pound for pound number 1???? after beating Lockett....go watch more boxing kid.

[Pullcounter]

Well most likely Kelly Pavlik will get moved into the P4P #1 spot in my eyes, I mean how could he not looking at the fighters he's fought, he's still undefeated and doesn't look like anybody will beat him.

Mayweather had a similar situation with Jones falling off the top spot when he fought Gatti a big puncher but heavy underdog.

I don't think Pavlik destroying Lockett moves him into the #1 p4p spot.

[Live Dog]

Both were impressive against lesser competition. Pavlik is in no way #1 now.

[MikeBrew328]

I watch a ton of boxing dude. But I just don't think you could put Calzaghe or Pacquaio, Calzaghe's biggest win was a 43 year old Hopkins, and Pacquaio lost to Morales. I could see Cotto, but he hasn't cleaned out 147 yet.

Name someone that will beat Pavlik in his division.

[abadger]

LMAO at this thread.