Pacquiao vs. Calzaghe: Who is P4P number ONE?

[johnm is...]

Pacquiao, there is no debate. he has been #2 for a long time. If the #1 retires, then the #2 becomes #1.

Like I said before, Roy Jones jr was #1, he loses a fight, #2 Bernard Hopkins becomes #1. Bernard hopkins loses a fight, #2 Floyd Mayweather becomes #1. Floyd retires, #2 Pacquiao becomes #1.

It's simple, logical and fair.

That's the problem, you're asking people to be simple, logical, and fair.

[Froch You]

Pacquiao

[QuCongee]

I don't know but I predict Pavlik will be p4p#1 by 2010.

[Pugilistic™]

Manny Pacquaio is number 2. Mayweather retires and then pac becomes number 1.

[Left Hook Tua]

it's so hard to judge p4p.

skills? resume?

skillswise , both have their strengths and both have their weaknesses , just like any other fighter.

resume , i give the edge to manny. though joe is undefeated , which is in his favor.

one way i like to look at it is , if i was a boxer in their weight class who would i rather be? who would i be more wary of fighting? who's record and resume would i rather have?

for me. i choose manny.

[Kilrain]

I'd say Pacquiao with Cotto following him. **** Calzaghe and his wins against untested opponents except for Benard. Yet he never looked completely dominant in that fight, even going down. Yeah, how about Pacquiao who demolishes P4P opponents, and Cotto who brutalizes his competition which is more respectable and tougher than Calzaghe's.

Yup, good post

[DiegoFuego]

Pacquiao without a doubt

[MakeDamnSure]

Pacquiao.......... Not the Slapper