THe greatest 25 all time boxers, is Mayweather on that list?

[RichCCFC]

Not even close.

[boxaholic]

All The Boxing Sites Have Officially Reverted Back Into

Cotto/dlh/boxer/margo Vs. Mayweather Sites.


MAYWEATHER: I SAID JUMP.

bOXING SITES: HOW HIGH?

I agree PBF is money for a reason but retired I can't believe. He will be back.

[El Chicano]

If he would have beat De La Hoya, Mosley, and Cotto he would be in my top 5 ever. Now its kind of hard to put him in my top 15.

He aint top 25, people only put him there because they speculate how good he his and how good he WOULD do against the best fighters. He didn't FIGHT the best fighters of his era, therefore he's unproven. Not top 25 of all time, are you kidding me. Maybe top 100.

[Left2body]

He may or may not be a top 25 fighter.....but I dont think he had a top 25 career.

He had a great career but can it can't be considered top 25. Much easier to argue that he is a top 25 boxer in terms of ability.

[Domain]

He aint top 25, people only put him there because they speculate how good he his and how good he WOULD do against the best fighters. He didn't FIGHT the best fighters of his era, therefore he's unproven. Not top 25 of all time, are you kidding me. Maybe top 100.

Exactly people also focus too much on no losses...floyd jr has 0 losses cause he carefully picked his foes on the move up.

Guys like sugar ray robinson fought guys every other week almost and had higher chances of losing but he maintained and undefeated career till he fought lamotta...ray robinson **** son floyd jr.

floyd jr even had the nerve to disrespect ray robinson and say he is better? wtf? just cause you got 0 losses and fought guy slike gatti, mitchell,hatton,past prime oscar and even ran against him,and weak minded judah?

[boxaholic]

Where are the days when fighters fought often. PBF 39 fights are the reason people don't give him his props. Maybe he should have fought more bums like the GREAT Chavez.

[El Chicano]

On skills he is def in the top 10.

No way man, think of all the thousands of boxers that have stepped in the ring in the past and the hundreds of world class athletes there are now. Don't let ignorance allow you to make a decision like that.

[boxaholic]

No way man, think of all the thousands of boxers that have stepped in the ring in the past and the hundreds of world class athletes there are now. Don't let ignorance allow you to make a decision like that.

Easy top 25. Good Pic

[Silencers]

Top 50 if he really does retire now.