Is Zaghe's win over Pudwill better than Floyd's win over Corrales?

[SkillspayBills]

Tucker Pudwill-Who?

Diego Corrales- 130 pound wrecking maching who was number 5 on the p4p list


One dumbass thread begets another.

[RichCCFC]

I'd say so.

Pudwill went 12 rounds with Ottke, the P4p hardest puncher of his era.

[SkillspayBills]

I'd say so.

Pudwill went 12 rounds with Ottke, the P4p hardest puncher of his era.

**** I forgot to make the poll public

[The Hammer]

Tocker Pudwill was just a short-notice replacement
when Joe scheduled opponent was injured.

He was Joe's least significant win - why do people keep bringing up his name?

Floyd fought Jesus Chavez (1-13-1)
at 130. Pudwill was a better win than him!

[SkillspayBills]

Tocker Pudwill was just a short-notice replacement
when Joe scheduled opponent was injured.

He was Joe's least significant win - why do people keep bringing up his name?

Floyd fought Jesus Chavez (1-13-1)
at 130. Pudwill was a better win than him!

Let me know how you mention a win for Floyd that was without a doubt while he was a prospect. I just stated a fight Zaghe had when he was a CHAMPION. Go home you hugger.

[RichCCFC]

Henry Brussels

At least Pudwill challenged for a World title.

[boxaholic]

Please people keep your pride in boxing. Are you kidding me. FLoyd by far. Calzaghe is a liked fighter but when i start hearing all this nonsense that his past fights are against better oppisition its plain ******. Joe beat a washed up hopkins, a up and coming Lacy, and a unproven Kessler. He is top 5 p4p. But the difference between floyd #1 and Joe #5 is HUGe. Joe needs to beat Pavlik, Roy Jones Jr. and Arthur Abraham to be considered pound for pound champ. If floyd beats de la hoya, Cotto, and maybe Sugar Shane Floyd will go down in history as the best boxer ever under Heavyweight. All props to the greatest Ali.

[Dynamite Kid]

to say Ricky overates Calzaghe is an understatment