Was Zaghe's win over Eubank better than Floyd's win over G. Hernandez?

[pesticid]

I like that you're not trying to refuse anything anybody says in your threads. You just post some air and expect us to agree or go away or something?

Refute that James was past it when he was an undefeated beast?

[Dirt E Gomez]

Refute that James was past it when he was an undefeated beast?

That couldn't be further from the point, which brings me back to my point. You can't defend ****.

[pesticid]

That couldn't be further from the point, which brings me back to my point. You can't defend ****.

Pls explain to me how Lights Out was past it. I mean try defend smth yourself.

[Dirt E Gomez]

Pls explain to me how Lights Out was past it. I mean try defend smth yourself.

That was a rough comparison drawn between 2 fighters that aren't in the actual discussion of this thread. It is the 1 thing that has been posted that is actually "debatable", but you can't acknowledge how basing "big" wins by using Calzaghe's only 4 while cherry picking Floyd's or only talking about what fighters were leading up to the fight; and that what they prove after the fact is meaningless.

To summarize:

[pesticid]

That was a rough comparison drawn between 2 fighters that aren't in the actual discussion of this thread. It is the 1 thing that has been posted that is actually "debatable", but you can't acknowledge how basing "big" wins by using Calzaghe's only 4 while cherry picking Floyd's or only talking about what fighters were leading up to the fight; and that what they prove after the fact is meaningless.

To summarize:

4 title fights for both guys, how am I cherry picking. Maybe I should mention Floyd's title fight at 140 - Gatti. Am I still cherry picking?

[Dirt E Gomez]

4 title fights for both guys, how am I cherry picking. Maybe I should mention Floyd's title fight at 140 - Gatti. Am I still cherry picking?

How are you cherry picking? Why use Castillo 1 and not Castillo 2? Why use Hernandez and not Corrales? Why use Baldomir and not Chavez?

[pesticid]

How are you cherry picking? Why use Castillo 1 and not Castillo 2? Why use Hernandez and not Corrales? Why use Baldomir and not Chavez?

Title fights that they won. How is that cherry picking?

[Dirt E Gomez]

Title fights that they won. How is that cherry picking?

I'm fine with semi-delusional nuthuggers, but if you honestly can't tell the difference then you should leave his forum immediately.

[Fox McCloud]

Title fights that they won. How is that cherry picking?

They are both undefeated genius... they have won all of their title fights.

It's true, Corrales is a better win than Baldomir. Castillo II is a better win than Castillo I. If you don't see that, then you truly are an idiot. If you do see that, then you are guilty of cherry picking.

[pesticid]

They are both undefeated genius... they have won all of their title fights.

It's true, Corrales is a better win than Baldomir. Castillo II is a better win than Castillo I. If you don't see that, then you truly are an idiot. If you do see that, then you are guilty of cherry picking.

Now picking fights for titles is cherry picking?
Hernadez
Castillo
Baldomir
DLH
Gatti

Floyd says he's 5 time weight division champ, and those are the wins that made him the champ