If Bernard did beat Calzaghe would he be considered as top 20

[MELLY-MEL...]

nah, to many other gr8 fighters above him.

[daggum]

A win means a lot regardless if it is controversial. Look at the win that Tito got vs DLH or the Taylor vs Bhop fights, or Whitaker vs DLH or Chavez, etc, etc. Look at Johnson for Christ Sake, he beats Dawson but he doesn't get rewarded and he drops out of the picture.

it's a win in the records but for hardcore fans who know better when anyone mentions oscar-tito the first thing that everyone thinks of is what a robbery and hopkins-calzaghe will be thought of similar but not as bad. actually it's better to just not think of that horrible fight and it should be stricken from the records and our minds.

[Motofan]

...Nope...

[Mr. Philadel]

well most media, professional boxers, and fans thought he did win the calzaghe fight so i don't think it really matters. a win over calzaghe wouldn't mean all that much as far as history goes since calzaghe never fought good opposition his whole career and will be remembered similar to sven ottke.

Wow! if Ricky sees this...lol

[Drunk Punch]

Top 20? Only in his dreams.