Who would win?? Amir OR SRR???

[The Gambler1981]

First of all i know this is a joke lol, i was in the thread about Joe Louis and Haye thread where he came up with this idea.

But I said great fighters are great fighters regardless of era.


When did i say anything like Amir Khan is great.

[KnockoutTheFat]

amir ****, ahemmm khan, shouldnt be mentioned in the same sentence with that Adonis

Well clearly if the guy can KTFO SRR in one round, there has to be some sort of comparison. But of course, like every other Tye Fields opponent, he will get KO'ed in the first round if he goes up against him.

[robjr]

LMAO at thread

[Boogie Nights]

First of all i know this is a joke lol, i was in the thread about Joe Louis and Haye thread where he came up with this idea.

But I said great fighters are great fighters regardless of era.


When did i say anything like Amir Khan is great.

and you also said that fighters today are better than the ones who fought in the robinson, and duran era. which is complete bs, like ive said before better athletism doesnt make a complete fighter. we got pretty damn good fighters today, but to compare their work ethic, their overall attitude, the lifestyle is little borderline beyond the point. just because our nutrition has improved, and the training has advanced it dont mean ****. no weight, supplements, or steroids or whatever these advanced athletes use is gonna hlep you in the ring against a 50s fighter like robbie.

all a complete fighter needs is a skipping rope, speed bag, a heavybag, and another body for sparring.

the heavyweights might have gotten bigger and maybe stronger and i admit would beat smaller guys like marciano, louis, dempsey. but that's a minority. To say that a guy like Wlad would rush through the heavyweight division of the 70s is redicilous. he'll be competitive but he'll neevr be dominant. his size will mkae him competitive, but size is not enough to compete with warrior animals of the old days.

like i said stop watching mayweather fights on youtube and get yourself introduced to the fight game better.

[The Gambler1981]

I did not say that you can think i said that but whatever you have no idea of my point of view and i do not care to clarify for you.

[Boogie Nights]

Well clearly if the guy can KTFO SRR in one round, there has to be some sort of comparison. But of course, like every other Tye Fields opponent, he will get KO'ed in the first round if he goes up against him.

well beating robbie is a tall order, so i would give him a total of 30 seconds of survival time. that's half a minute kothefat, we talking history here.

tell how do you think balboa, another great southpaw, would match against fields. let's keep in mind, rocko beat creed twice (first time was a robbery), he beat clubber, and the very dangerous ivan drago.

and came back at 60 years old to be robbed against the overrated dixon

do you see the itallion stallion possibly pulling another coin trick on beast that is fields?

[Boogie Nights]

I did not say that you can think i said that but whatever you have no idea of my point of view and i do not care to clarify for you.

i already know your point of view:

Why are you still here i thought we agreed to go our seperate ways? Anyways look it up. I am not trying to **** on Lamotta or SRR i could care less they fought 4 ****ing times and SRR beat him 3 times so even if 2 were fixed there are still 2 that show who is better. I am sorry LaMotta was tied up with the mob as was MOST of boxing at the time and ******** industry.

you said they fought 4 times when in fact they fought 6

this right here proves you know **** about boxing. like you dont even know about the **** you talking about, but you doing it for the sake of the arguement.

anyway you just owned yourself

[Action Blackson]

There are actually people that honestly believe Khan could beat SRR? Is the mentality of this board really that low?

[$partacus]

i already know your point of view:



you said they fought 4 times when in fact they fought 6

omg who made this thread, if its a English man(boy) i'm ashamed to be from the same country

[KnockoutTheFat]

well beating robbie is a tall order, so i would give him a total of 30 seconds of survival time. that's half a minute kothefat, we talking history here.

tell how do you think balboa, another great southpaw, would match against fields. let's keep in mind, rocko beat creed twice (first time was a robbery), he beat clubber, and the very dangerous ivan drago.

and came back at 60 years old to be robbed against the overrated dixon

do you see the itallion stallion possibly pulling another coin trick on beast that is fields?

Balboa is the pure definition of a Cinderella Man. So it wouldn't be too farfetched to say that he could be competitive with Tye. But that's the problem: he's only gonna be competitive. He'll have no chance in hell of ever winning the fight.

However, being the fact that Rocky will be competitive, the public will demand a rematch because he will be the only one giving him the closest shot of losing (not that Tye will ever be defeated, but you know what I mean) and this is where the disaster starts. Rocky will run into a plethora of shots from Fields that wouldn't just kill any man, it would kill Iron Man. It would be like Drago-Creed all over, but Tye would end the fight in a minute. Then he proceeds to KO Max Kellerman for being a Balboa nuthugger.