BoxRec Ranking

[miron_lang]

the US have 4 fighters ranked at the top of their division followed by


UK : 3
Pilipinas : 3
Mexico : 2


But their Top 10 lbs 4 lbs looks like this

1 Joe Calzaghe light heavyweight
2 Floyd Mayweather Jr welterweight
3 Kelly Pavlik middleweight
4 Bernard Hopkins light heavyweight
5 Israel Vazquez super bantamweight
6 Manny Pacquiao super featherweight
7 Juan Manuel Marquez super featherweight
8 Ronald Wright middleweight
9 Rafael Marquez super bantamweight
10 Wladimir Klitschko

Hopkins above Pacquiao???
Winky Wright at 9 ???
Mayweather at 2???
Kelly Pavlik at 3????


I know its based on a formula but still.........


thoughts?

[THe TRiNiTY]

Numbers can HELP you decide something, they should never decide it for you. When they do, you get things like Mayweather at number 2.

[Flab]

the US have 4 fighters ranked at the top of their division followed by


UK : 3
Pilipinas : 3
Mexico : 2


But their Top 10 lbs 4 lbs looks like this

1 Joe Calzaghe light heavyweight
2 Floyd Mayweather Jr welterweight
3 Kelly Pavlik middleweight
4 Bernard Hopkins light heavyweight
5 Israel Vazquez super bantamweight
6 Manny Pacquiao super featherweight
7 Juan Manuel Marquez super featherweight
8 Ronald Wright middleweight
9 Rafael Marquez super bantamweight
10 Wladimir Klitschko

Hopkins above Pacquiao???
Winky Wright at 9 ???
Mayweather at 2???
Kelly Pavlik at 3????


I know its based on a formula but still.........


thoughts?

Marquez should be 6 and Pacquiao shouldn't even be in it.

[miron_lang]

Numbers can HELP you decide something, they should never decide it for you. When they do, you get things like Mayweather at number 2.

How about Hopkins that high? or Pavlik at 3?

Maybe they should modify the Formula

[miron_lang]

Marquez should be 6 and Pacquiao shouldn't even be in it.

Yeah. Its Mythical and subjective right?

[shadeyfizzle]

Marquez should be 6 and Pacquiao shouldn't even be in it.

Lol!!! ****ing hater. Lol. But you actually think Calzaghe should be at 1 and Pavlik at 3?? Get the **** outta here with hater ass.

[Flab]

Lol!!! ****ing hater. Lol. But you actually think Calzaghe should be at 1 and Pavlik at 3?? Get the **** outta here with hater ass.

Oscar de la Hoya #1
Juan Manuel Marquez #2
Rafael Marquez #3
Floyd Mayweather #4

[THe TRiNiTY]

How about Hopkins that high? or Pavlik at 3?

Maybe they should modify the Formula

They can keep the formula. But they should use better judgment on top of that. The formula should only HELP them make a decision, not be the decision.

But, they are trying to be a factual site, as factual as can be, based on numbers. I get it. It's just open for pretty rational crtiques.

[shadeyfizzle]

Oscar de la Hoya #1
Juan Manuel Marquez #2
Rafael Marquez #3
Floyd Mayweather #4

You must either be joking...or you must be the Marquez brothers' gay japanese lover and like seeing oscar dress in heels and fishnets because that is a ******ass top 4.