which undefeated fighters should have a loss right now??

[joshyp18]

only people with PBCS know the second one.

lol i agree

[pbftxrs316]

mayweather this thread was obviously set up to start another argument for him. not being rude or nothing but everyone knows he lost to castillo and DLH was a draw.

of course not everyone knows. hell, the judges sure didn't, and they were right in picking floyd over castillo, just not the points they gave him. yes, floyd did beat jose in a close fought battle and beat oscar soundly 9 rounds to 3, maybe 8 to 4. oscar wasn't even close to beating floyd in that fight, he lost, face it boy. you must love mexican fighters huh? damn kid.

[robjr]

mayweather and otke like others have said..

but also..

sergio mora. -rematch against manfredo. and draw against ayala..
chad dawson. -vs johnson
zsolt erdei. -sd in germany vs tito mendoza...
john duddy. -his last fight against no namer.
dzindruik. - his last fight..
Calzaghe - VS Reid
yuri foreman - vs thompson for sure.. have yet to see tsurkan fight.
demetrius hopkins - vs steve forbes.

[robjr]

Joe Calzaghe.

The Robin Reid fight, and I had Hopkins winning by 1 point.

I agree.. Ive been saying this for a while.. I dont think alot of people have seen this fight. It was close and competitive, but It was still obvious Reid got the better of Joe..

[Bizzle_LDN]

which undefeated fighter do you think has already lost a fight and got a gift decision and should have a loss on his record??

Chad Dawson!!!

[bsrizpac]

The PBCS way of scoring a fight:

1. Is the fighter from my home country? Automatic win.

2. Do I dislike or hate a fighter or his fans? Automatic loss.

[ßringer]

I agree.. Ive been saying this for a while.. I dont think alot of people have seen this fight. It was close and competitive, but It was still obvious Reid got the better of Joe..

In a fight you always want to be the man who does more damage to the other guy than you took, Reid was definitely that guy in that fight.

[x-PeROxiDE-x]

I agree.. Ive been saying this for a while.. I dont think alot of people have seen this fight. It was close and competitive, but It was still obvious Reid got the better of Joe..

I'm not so sure. I had Reid winning by a single point, but a lot of that fight was subjective.

Calzaghe didn't spar at all for that fight due to injury, and the fight was as close to Reids backyard as yhou are going to get without actually being there, so you can't even call home decision.

With Calzaghe eating big right hands down he middle all night, and the fight being so close to Reid's backyard, it just doesn't stink that much of a robbery. If the fight was as close as I scored it, it would have surely gone to Reid. Maybe the judges saw something that we simply didn't.

[joshyp18]

of course not everyone knows. hell, the judges sure didn't, and they were right in picking floyd over castillo, just not the points they gave him. yes, floyd did beat jose in a close fought battle and beat oscar soundly 9 rounds to 3, maybe 8 to 4. oscar wasn't even close to beating floyd in that fight, he lost, face it boy. you must love mexican fighters huh? damn kid.

no, you must love mayweather like 50 does. 9-3 agesnt DLH think your in love mate

[bsrizpac]

Post your scorecard, round by round and why mate.