Why can't we have fightoffs?

[boxaholic]

I know that promoters will never make it happen but in a dream world which division would you want to see a 4 man fightoff? I would have at Welterweight
1. Floyd Mayweather jr. vs. 4. Shane Mosley
2. Miguel Cotto vs. 3. Antonio Margarito
Lightweight
1. Manny Pacquiao vs. 4. Joel Casamayor
2. Nate Cambell vs. 3. Juan Manuel Marquez
Super Middleweight/Middleweight
1. Joe Calzaghe vs. 4. Arthur Abraham
2. Kelly Pavlik vs. 3. Winky Wright
Heavyweight
1. Wladimir Klitschko vs. 4. David Haye
2. Samuel Peter vs. 3. Ruslan Changaev
Let me Know where did I mess up and who do you think would win in this mini tournament?

[The Hammer]

This is a great idea, but because of the sanctioning organizations and promoters, it cannot happen.

I'd like to see all eliminators become four-fighter tournaments, like they had with the IBF heavyweights last year.

[frankpaganini]

I know that promoters will never make it happen but in a dream world which division would you want to see a 4 man fightoff? I would have at Welterweight
1. Floyd Mayweather jr. vs. 4. Shane Mosley
2. Miguel Cotto vs. 3. Antonio Margarito
Lightweight
1. Manny Pacquiao vs. 4. Joel Casamayor
2. Nate Cambell vs. 3. Juan Manuel Marquez
Super Middleweight/Middleweight
1. Joe Calzaghe vs. 4. Arthur Abraham
2. Kelly Pavlik vs. 3. Winky Wright
Heavyweight
1. Wladimir Klitschko vs. 4. David Haye
2. Samuel Peter vs. 3. Ruslan Changaev
Let me Know where did I mess up and who do you think would win in this mini tournament?

floyd beats shane
cotto beats margarito

pacquiao (easily) beats casamayor
JMM (easily) beats campbell

calzaghe beats abraham
pavlik v. winky (too close to choose a winner)

Wlad vs. haye (too close to choose a winner)
Peter (easily) beats Changaev

so yeah...just my opinion

[THe TRiNiTY]

At JR. Featherweight...
1. Vazquez/4. Daniel Ponce De Leon
2. Rafael Marquez/3. Celestu=ino Caballero

Featherweight...
1. Chris John/4. Jorge Linares
2. Robert Guerrero/3. Injin Chi

JR. Middleweight (Just because it needs a champion)
1. Vernon Forrest/4. Ricardo Mayorga
2. Verno Phillips/3. Ike Quartey

Though, I have a feeling that would lead to Ike/Vernon II. Which, would suck if they had a decision like that again.

[frankpaganini]

At JR. Featherweight...
1. Vazquez/4. Daniel Ponce De Leon
2. Rafael Marquez/3. Celestu=ino Caballero

Featherweight...
1. Chris John/4. Jorge Linares
2. Robert Guerrero/3. Injin Chi

JR. Middleweight (Just because it needs a champion)
1. Vernon Forrest/4. Ricardo Mayorga
2. Verno Phillips/3. Ike Quartey

Though, I have a feeling that would lead to Ike/Vernon II. Which, would suck if they had a decision like that again.

vasquez over de leon (to end the de leon hype)
marquez over caballero
which equals marquez v. vasquez 4 (we all win again)

Linares over john
Robert Guerrero over chi (in a close fight in my opinion)

i'm going to go against the popular vote and say mayorga over forrest
and quartey over phillips...