A PRIME Winky Wright vs. Miguel Cotto??

[kayjay]

At any weight Winky is still the natural much bigger man.

Of course. But you said you were talking "in a p4p sense," which means you don't count who is bigger. Cotto is better for his size. Winky is bigger so would beat him.

[BMWM3P]

People here give Winky Wright to much credit, he was beat by Fernando Vargas. Winky beat Trinnidad easy because Trinidad gets flustered and he truly was lost in this fight. Cotto's is much smarter he would take the fight to him and actually make him use something other than the jab.

[SkillspayBills]

classic boxer vs. puncher matchup..winky takes his head off.

Yea Cotto's slick boxing skills can't overcome Winky's Tyson like power.

[Dorian]

who the fuc* voted for Cotto by ko??

[Addison]

Winky by KO. Cotto has been hurt by Malignaggi, Quintana, and Gomez.

Wright would put a sustained straight punch beating on Cotto. Miguel would lunge his way into a whole series of counterpunches. Over and over.

[chibomber]

Prime Winky beats all of our top 3 WW now

[FUC_U_PAYME]

Cotto late ko or ud

[RichCCFC]

If this is Burner trying to take a pop at Cotto using by Winky to win a poll over him then it just isn't working... Winky beats Floyd too.

[Bad_Barracuda]

If it's p4p then it's Cotto.


Head to head, given the size advantage, Winky wins very comfortably.


You need to specify p4p. As it stands people chose Winky b/c he would indeed win head to head.

We don't even know how much Cotto weighs come fight-night..

So the size advantage is nill..

It comes down to skill..Winky is more skilled than Cotto..

[BROOKLYN CESAR]

Winky UD...EASILY.

Winky in his prime is a tough fight for anyone!!! But i think it would be very close!!!