what if: James Toney vs. Winky Wright @ 160 ?

[boxingsmash69]

who wins this one.

The middleweight Toney vs. the Winky that fought Taylor. at 160

the only difference in their reach/height, is that wright is 5'10 1/2, and toney is 5'10

[Dorian]

James "lights out" Toney by UD

[Silencers]

I'd pick Toney by close decision, it'd be a pretty dull fight.

[Jim Jeffries]

Lol at Wright by KO/TKO. Prime motivated Toney too much for Winky, I'd say Toney by UD, but at 160 he had some pretty serious power, he could catch Winky.

[Dorian]

Toney was a beast back in his middleweight- super middleweight times

[MANGLER]

Winky is a bigger and stronger MW than Toney was. And he don't throw enough punches for a counter punch artist like Toney to take advantage of. Close, dull fight with Winky winnin it close, either 116-112 or 115-113.

[krazyx19]

Winky is a bigger and stronger MW than Toney was.

Toney is a Heavyweight now and seemed like he a natural.

[Thread Stealer]

Toney was pretty inconsistent at 160. He often fought to the level of opposition, and he was still green and improving. By the time Wright got to 160, he had a ton of experience on him in addition to his skills.

I'm leaning towards Wright by debatable decision.

Toney had a few debatable decisions at 160, and also at 175 and HW for that matter.

[-Hyperion-]

wright by decision...since you cant get robbed in fantasy match ups...