Is it possible for Roy to get back on the p4p list with a win over Joe?

[THE REED]

Theoretically...

If in fact roy did get a fight with Joe #3 p4p fighter, and Roy beat him... would you put Roy back on the top 10?

If no, what else would he have to do?

[Orion]

I think thatd be more than enough also the Trinidad win....sure.

[Xyei]

Hell yeah he would! If Roy could win in impressive fashion against Calzaghe, I think he should rightfully be discussed in P4P mention.

[My Name Is...]

Roy will whoop Calz ass, EASY. He will toy with Calslappy and KO him.

[THE REED]

especilly with floyd fighting oscar and ricky hatton... not p4p fighters anymore

all im saying is if bernard can land his right hand all night long

do yuo have any idea how much faster and more accurate roys right hand is? he also has more in the tank than bernard as far as workrate, and he DOES use combinations... i dont think i saw one combo from bernard

[THE REED]

Hell yeah he would! If Roy could win in impressive fashion against Calzaghe, I think he should rightfully be discussed in P4P mention.

i think he should... i think if u beat one of the top guys, you should be on the top

[My Name Is...]

Roy will do this to Mr.Slappy

[Scott9945]

I think thatd be more than enough also the Trinidad win....sure.

The Trinidad win was worthless, IMO. I actually thought beating Hanshaw was more impressive. A win over Calzaghe would be a totally different matter however and yes, it probably does get Roy back in the top 10. Not to mention what it would do for his all time status.

[THE REED]

The Trinidad win was worthless, IMO. I actually thought beating Hanshaw was more impressive. A win over Calzaghe would be a totally different matter however and yes, it probably does get Roy back in the top 10. Not to mention what it would do for his all time status.

and i think thats WHY this fight is a big deal...

the whats IF is pretty big

[THE REED]

The Trinidad win was worthless, IMO. I actually thought beating Hanshaw was more impressive. A win over Calzaghe would be a totally different matter however and yes, it probably does get Roy back in the top 10. Not to mention what it would do for his all time status.

I dont think it was worthless... obviously he doesnt get credit for BEATING tito... but i think he should get credit in the performace he displayed, the hand speed he showed... his defense, and the combinations he had... and 2 knockdowns...

when you add in his age of 39...

it wasnt worthless at all