Do you think Calzaghe is a GREAT FIGHTER now?

[BattlingNelson]

I just wonder if people now would consider that Joe Calzaghe is great fighter?

Most of us who has followed Joe's career knew that he was SPECIAL. Will a win over a legend, who happens to be 43, be enough to consider Joe great?

[MELLY-MEL...]

always have, and always will consider joe a great fighter.

[-Antonio-]

He's always been a great fighter. He belongs in the Hopkins, Jones, Toney catagory now.

[sjomcik]

yes he is and he was before

[warp1432]

He always was a great fighter and still is.

[unity768]

I thought he was a great fighter after dominating Lacy. A shoe-in Hall of famer

[BattlingNelson]

Cool to read the replies. Especially from the yanks.

I think he is very special. He has a style that doesn't compare to anything the world has ever seen. He is so difficult to beat and it's hard for me to see anybody dealing effectively with his style. I can't think of any fighter with the ability to execute a game-winning plan.

It's difficult for me to see what is left for Calzaghe to prove. He could retire now.