Where does Calzaghe rank in your P4P list?

[MentalExecution]

Where does he stand after the Hopkins fight in your opinion?

[Left Hook Tua]

i had him 8th before. now i have him either 3rd or 4th haven't decided yet.

1. mayweather
2. manny
3-4. cotto or calzaghe

[thegreatone1]

1st.

Mayweathers resume is ultra weak now (Cottos is better) and Pacquaio lost his last bout.

[Technical_Skill]

1st.

Mayweathers resume is ultra weak now (Cottos is better) and Pacquaio lost his last bout.

Corrales
Castillo x2
De la Hoya
Hatton
Judah,

Nah mate, Mayweather beat better fighters, fought better fighters, and is a better fighter by some distance than both cotto and calzaghe.

[Silencers]

3rd on mine.

[Ryn0]

3rd on mine.

co-sign 3rd for me aswell.

[Left Hook Tua]

1st.

Mayweathers resume is ultra weak now (Cottos is better) and Pacquaio lost his last bout.

ultra weak? an oscar win is on the same level as hopkins win. a hatton win is much better than a kessler win. joe is good but his opposition has not always been. floyd has wins over much better fighters and in less fights as well.

lost? the record says he won. a few hop fans are saying he won too. fans opinions don't count. the only ones that does are the judges of that bout. even if he lost , manny looked a lot better in that "loss" than calzaghe did in this win. bernard isn't even top 10 p4p. juan manuel was and still is.

[x-PeROxiDE-x]

Right now he's a solid 2nd, with a claim for first if he can beat RJJ, Pavlik, Dawson or tarver.

He could be 1st now, especially if Mayweather decides on a rematch with Hatton.

[T-97]

1-Mayweather
2-Pacquiao
3-Calzaghe