Joe Calzaghe is not a P4P Fighter.

[MELLY-MEL...]

I still have Hopkins higher then him after the loss.

Joe looked terrible.

who looks good against bhop??? don't 4 get to pay me son!

[Burner]

he is top 10 p4p, just definately not top 3 in my book. he woulda had to dominate hopkins to be considered for that

Not even top 10..I can name 10 fighters better then him.

[sterling]

I still have Hopkins higher then him after the loss.

Joe looked terrible.

aww did u lose ur points to ? ***** lol stop crying .
He out worked and made hopkins look like a old man he lost simple as.
No one looks gd against hopkins no more no one since jermain taylor.

[Addition]

Wow, just wow.

[TonyJ]

Look what Hopkins did to Tarver. Calzaghe clearly won against a top5 p4p-fighter, so whats the deal?

[thegreatone1]

Not even top 10..I can name 10 fighters better then him.

Calzaghe is P4P 1

You **** chop.

[.Mik.]

That being said, were you impressed by Zag?

Impressed by his resilience? Yes.

Impressed by his ability to change plans and adapt when things arent going his way? Yes.

Impressed by a victory over a bad style match up and a HOF fighter? Yes.

Impressed by the performance? No.

[Ryn0]

Calzaghe is P4P top 3 right now. NO ONE has ever looked good against Hopkins including RJJ where they traded jabs for 12 rounds an nothing else.

[Jim Jeffries]

Not even top 10..I can name 10 fighters better then him.

Wait, aren't you the clown that has Malignaggi in their top 10?




Newsflash. PAUL WILLIAMS SUCKS.

[deliveryman]

My definition of P4P is, if everyone weighed exactly the same, who would win.

I think a 175lb version of Manny Pacquiao would put Joe into a coma. A 175lb version of Floyd Mayweather would cruise to a UD, Juan Marquez would probably KO him, as well.

Hence Calzaghe is at #4 on my list.