From a scale of 1-5, rate the following fighters

[KnockoutTheFat]

Rate these fighters based on these attributes: punching power, hand-speed, foot-speed, and stamina.
Antonio Margarito
Miguel Cotto
Joe Calzaghe
Bernard Hopkins

If you must, you may use half-points.

[THE REED]

Rate these fighters based on these attributes: punching power, hand-speed, foot-speed, and stamina.
Antonio Margarito
Miguel Cotto
Joe Calzaghe
Bernard Hopkins

If you must, you may use half-points.

Antonio Margarito
punching power: 4
hand-speed: 3
foot-speed: 3 3/4
stamina: 4 1/2

Miguel Cotto
punching power: 3 3/4
hand-speed: 4
foot-speed: 3 3/4
stamina: 4 1/4

Joe Calzaghe
punching power: 3
hand-speed: 4 1/2
foot-speed: 4 1/2
stamina: 4 1/4

Bernard Hopkins
punching power: 3 1/2
hand-speed: 3 3/4
foot-speed: 3
stamina: 4

[KingTito]

Margarito-3
Cotto-4
Calzaghe-5
Hopkins-4 (right now)

[TommyGunn.]

Rate these fighters based on these attributes: punching power, hand-speed, foot-speed, and stamina.
Antonio Margarito
Miguel Cotto
Joe Calzaghe
Bernard Hopkins

If you must, you may use half-points.

Antonio Margarito

punching power - 4
Hand Speed - 3
Foot Speed - 2
Stamina - 5

Miguel Cotto

Punching Power - 4
Hand Speed - 4
Foot Speed - 3
Stamina - 5

Joe Calzaghe

Punching Power - 3
Hand speed - 5
Foot Speed - 4
Stamina - 5

Bernard Hopkins

Punching Power - 4
Hand Speed - 3
Foot Speed - 3
Stamina - 3

Hopkins would get 10 out of 5 for smarts though if it was an option. LOL!

[FRKO]

Antonio Margarito
Punching Power - 4.00
Hand Speed - 3.00
Foot Speed - 3.00
Stamina - 4.50

Miguel Cotto
Punching Power - 4.00
Hand Speed - 4.00
Foot Speed - 3.50
Stamina - 4.50

Joe Calzaghe
Punching Power - 3.50 (without injuries, 4.25)
Hand speed - 4.75
Foot Speed - 4.50
Stamina - 4.75

Bernard Hopkins
Punching Power - 4.00
Hand Speed - 3.00
Foot Speed - 3.50
Stamina - 4.00

[JcourT]

Margarito - 3
Cotto - 5
Calzaghe - 4
Hopkins - 4

[adrsan84]

Antonio Margarito

punching power - 4
Hand Speed - 3
Foot Speed - 2
Stamina - 5

Miguel Cotto

Punching Power - 4
Hand Speed - 4
Foot Speed - 3
Stamina - 5

Joe Calzaghe

Punching Power - 3
Hand speed - 5
Foot Speed - 4
Stamina - 5

Bernard Hopkins

Punching Power - 4
Hand Speed - 3
Foot Speed - 3
Stamina - 3

Hopkins would get 10 out of 5 for smarts though if it was an option. LOL!

I'd disagree with Cotto having the same amount of stamina as Margarito and Calzaghe. Watch the last few rounds of the mosley fight, he didn't have the extra gear to put it away in fashion, he just squeaked by instead. That fight wasn't fought at a torrid pace either, it took some skill and varsitility which Cotto has plenty of, but the lask of conditioning in the end didn't allow him to close the show as strong as he could have.

I do agree on your assesment of Margarito's foot speed though, he is very foot slow, but his hand speed isn't as slow as people make it out to be, otherwise he couldn't have thrashed the punchcount record with over 1600 punches in one fight.

[black.ink]

Antonio Margarito
punching power: 4.25
hand-speed: 3.5
foot-speed: 3.5
stamina: 4

Miguel Cotto
punching power: 3.75
hand-speed: 4
foot-speed: 3.5
stamina: 4

Joe Calzaghe
punching power: 3.5
hand-speed: 4.25
foot-speed: 4
stamina: 4.5

Bernard Hopkins
punching power: 3.5
hand-speed: 3.5
foot-speed: 3.5
stamina: 4[/QUOTE]

[KnockoutTheFat]

Margarito - 3
Cotto - 5
Calzaghe - 4
Hopkins - 4

Margarito-3
Cotto-4
Calzaghe-5
Hopkins-4 (right now)

err... there was a criteria for the ratings
nvm... I should've put it on the title
well here's my list

Margarito
Punching Power - 4.25
Hand Speed - 3
Foot Speed - 3
Stamina - 5

Cotto
Punching Power - 4
Hand Speed - 4
Foot Speed - 4
Stamina - 4

Calzaghe
Punching Power - 3.75
Hand Speed - 5
Foot Speed - 4.25
Stamina - 4.5

Hopkins
Punching Power - 4
Hand Speed - 3.5
Foot Speed - 3.75
Stamina - 4

[TommyGunn.]

I'd disagree with Cotto having the same amount of stamina as Margarito and Calzaghe. Watch the last few rounds of the mosley fight, he didn't have the extra gear to put it away in fashion, he just squeaked by instead. That fight wasn't fought at a torrid pace either, it took some skill and varsitility which Cotto has plenty of, but the lask of conditioning in the end didn't allow him to close the show as strong as he could have.

I do agree on your assesment of Margarito's foot speed though, he is very foot slow, but his hand speed isn't as slow as people make it out to be, otherwise he couldn't have thrashed the punchcount record with over 1600 punches in one fight.

I would say Cotto fights at much the same pace from the start of the fight untill the end of the fight, and its a very quick pace.