Which style would be best to Beat Calzaghe?

[SweetScience93]

A question for yall , if we all agree that a younger super middleweight james toney would have beaten calzaghe then why are they saying calzaghe is the greatest SMW of all time (they said so in the HBO countdown show )

[Liaison]

Toney was to slow a starter for Joe...

[HappyBoxingFan]

A question for yall , if we all agree that a younger super middleweight james toney would have beaten calzaghe then why are they saying calzaghe is the greatest SMW of all time (they said so in the HBO countdown show )

Calzaghe has stayed there longer... I think that's a questionable determination though...

[Silencers]

A question for yall , if we all agree that a younger super middleweight james toney would have beaten calzaghe then why are they saying calzaghe is the greatest SMW of all time (they said so in the HBO countdown show )

Because Toney didn't stay at 168 for a long period.

[squealpiggy]

I don't think Toney would have beaten Calzaghe, he was too static.

[SweetScience93]

I don't think Toney would have beaten Calzaghe, he was too static.

Elaborate Please

[squealpiggy]

He didn't use his feet. Joe is too fast and too busy and too mobile.

[Dynamite Kid]

Well when u see how Calzaghe struggled with rough/rugged fighters like Robin Ried & Bika i think a young Hopkins would have had a very good chance at beating him

i think a Prime James Toney would give Calzaghe fits aswell

[Burner]

Roy Jones.....Hopkins....James Toney...Winky Wright.

[Dynamite Kid]

A question for yall , if we all agree that a younger super middleweight james toney would have beaten calzaghe then why are they saying calzaghe is the greatest SMW of all time (they said so in the HBO countdown show )

Because styles make fights

Montell Griffin is not a better fighter than Jones JR & James Toney but thier were times in both fights where he outboxed the pair of them