Your top 10 P4P and why

[CraigM]

his skills are up there. very good skills and very talented.

but those i put in front of him has fought way better competition. who you fight is more important than an 0 on your record.

a win over past prime kostya is better than a win against lacy AND kessler. tell sharmba mitchell tzsyu was washed up. a loss by a junior welterweight to the p4p #1 and undisputed best at 147 is not a loss to me in my book.

Fair play to sticking to your decision, i'd put Calzaghe ahead of Hatton everytime but it's good you have your own opinions on this stuff.

[Left Hook Tua]

Fair play to sticking to your decision, i'd put Calzaghe ahead of Hatton everytime but it's good you have your own opinions on this stuff.

he's more talented and skilled than hatton but the 168 division has been pretty light. plus as a tua fan i like the guys that win with heart and determination. hatton has it in spades.

if calzaghe beats hopkins i'll put him #4 or maybe even past cotto and put him #3. old or not. hopkins is still hopkins. i think calzaghe wins in a close , ugly fight.

[xcaref]

JMM should be ranked the same as or at the least, one notch lower than Pacman.

[Left Hook Tua]

JMM should be ranked the same as or at the least, one notch lower than Pacman.

nope.

close fights , and arguably you can say he beat manny , against one great fighter doesn't make you great as well.

taylor would've beat chavez if it wasn't for the bad stoppage. if chavez woke up with meldrick's legacy he would jump out of a high story building and cut his throat on the way down.

bowe beat holyfield 2 out of 3 times. holyfield is still ranked better in my book.

[Talon]

Cotto
Mayweather
Pacquiao
Hopkins
Jones
Margarito
Hatton
Marquez

^miines the best

[Left Hook Tua]

Cotto
Mayweather
Pacquiao
Hopkins
Jones
Margarito
Hatton
Marquez

^miines the best

top 10 p4p is subjective and you can argue yours is the best. just add 2 more fighters though. we don't do top 8's here. i wish i can do top 9 so wladimir is not on my list. :-)

[xcaref]

No one's mentioned Ivan Calderon, who's 108 lbs to Hopkins' 160/168 or Wlad's 200+.

[Left Hook Tua]

No one's mentioned Ivan Calderon, who's 108 lbs to Hopkins' 160/168 or Wlad's 200+.

he'll get on there.

he'll be on everybody's list after a couple more fights.

[Diego Morales]

1)Pac
2)Mayweather
3)Calzaghe
4)Vazquez
5)Cotto
6)Hopkins
7)Rafeal Marquez
8)Juan Manuel Marquez
9)Ivan Calderon
10)Kelly Pavlik

[MakeDamnSure]

1. Pac
2. Calzaghe
3. Cotto
4. Mayweather (Dropped down Because of inactivity & Rematch w/ Oscar)
5. Hopkins
6. Vazquez
7. Pavlik
8. Winky Wright
9. Juan Marquez
10. Rafael Marquez