Something i have noticed here PBF/Cotto related is Mosley vs Oscar argument...

[Tyson2k7]

Some people on here give full credit to Cotto for beating Mosley yet diss Mayweather for beating De La Hoya?

The argument i've seen is Mosley beat Oscar twice! Really? Mosley beat De La Hoya 2 times? First off Mosley only beat Oscar 1 time and that was in 2000 in their first meeting. To say that Mosley won the rematch against Oscar is ******. Go watch the fight for yourself its not close.

To make matters worse not only did Oscar beat Mosley in the rematch, he beat him apparently on roids! So with this said i think PBF should get the same value of credit for beating Oscar as Cotto gets for beating Mosley.

Thoughts?

[Ray*]

Last time i check the records Mosley had the "W" next to his name against Oscar.

[Tyson2k7]

Last time i check the records Mosley had the "W" next to his name against Oscar.

Did you watch the fight?

[RichCCFC]

That's a fair point. Floyd also had to go up a Weight class to fight Oscar. I think the arguement is Shane has still got more left in the tank than Oscar after Oscar retired for a few years.