Pacquiao - Marquez II Rerun on HBO now

[We want Floyd]

I saw the rerun tonight, this time w/ the sound off, and I ended up w/ the same exact scorecard. 115-113 for JMM!

I don't have my original scorecard anymore. I wonder if I scored the rounds exactly the way I had it last week, hmm. Anyway, there were some tough rounds to score, no "funny smellin" judges on this one, imho.

[PrtyBoyDlicious]

I watched the re-run...and here's my unbiased score card:

JMM winning rounds: 2, 6, 7, 8, 11 & 12
PAC winning rounds: 1, 3, 4, 5, 9, 10

PAC winning by 1 point due to 10-8 score in rnd 3 knockdown: 114-113

[Lazy Liberal]

I saw the rerun tonight, this time w/ the sound off, and I ended up w/ the same exact scorecard. 115-113 for JMM!

I don't have my original scorecard anymore. I wonder if I scored the rounds exactly the way I had it last week, hmm. Anyway, there were some tough rounds to score, no "funny smellin" judges on this one, imho.

I scored the following:
1 pac
2 Marquez
3 Pac 10-8
4 Pac
5 even
6 Marquez
7 Pac
8 Marquez
9 Even
10 Pac
11 Marquez
12 Marquez



Pac Wins.

[King Koopa]

I thought Marquez won, but it was close, good fight

[UncleLeo]

I hate being indecisive and getting in the habit of calling rounds even, but in fights such as this I think it is imperative to call the really close rounds a draw and let the decisive rounds truly decide the fight so there is no dispute.

For example, if fighter A easily wins round 1 but fighter 2 barely "wins" round 2, maybe due to being the title holder or throwing one extra punch, is that two round stretch really even in the fans' eyes? I dont think so.

With that said, hell of a fight even the second time around.