james toney vs roy jones jr @168

[sterling]

who wins? i pick james toney because he wudnet be wieght drained and stronger at super middle but was wieght drained before the fi ght with roy jones he would win if he had a rematch tbh.
He had to starv himself at middlewieght and his last fight at super mid which was against roy but if they were to rm i do believe he would win by ko or sd.

[RichCCFC]

Roy already won..

[Derranged]

Roy Jones Jr. End of thread.

[Scott9945]

who wins? i pick james toney because he wudnet be wieght drained and stronger at super middle he had to starv himself at middlewieght and i do believe he would win by ko or sd.

When they fought each other it was at 168.

[sterling]

Roy won when james was wieght drained then never gave him his rematch very similar to marvin hagler vs sugar ray leonard because he knew he got lucky that he had it so easy but didnt want to risk losing.

[sterling]

Roy Jones Jr. End of thread.

poll says different

[Jolly Roger]

Roy was always better than Toney IMO.