Who wins at 130lbs? Floyd Jr. or Juan Manuel Marquez?

[xcaret]

Juan Manuel has losses & he doesnt even have a better resume than Floyd. Floyd hands down.

probably the most dumbest post i've seen so far... (the pinoys not included of course)

[xcaret]

Ok, so everyone assumes based on accomplishments, rather than how they see the fight play out? Did nobody watch JMM vs Pac? JMM timing BEAT SPEED.

yep just look at my sig...

[shadeyfizzle]

probably the most dumbest post i've seen so far... (the pinoys not included of course)

dumb is spending roughly 5,000 us dollars for round trip tickets from mexico city to indonesea and lodging to fight for 30,000 us dollars to lose the featherweight belt

[tyson]

Well, I just rewatched the Marquez, Pac fight and thought about how great of a boxer JMM is. In my opinion one of the best technical boxers of this era. He does everything seemly perfect. So then something clicks. Wait a second, another cat thinks he's the best. They've both fought or are at 130lbs, so let's assume they fought each other. Not so hard.

He does not do everything perfect. Not even close.
First of all, he's got absolutely no defense for a straight left.
After the first fight I expected JMM to at least neutralize Pacman's left hand.
He didn't.

He counters too wildly, swinging away with imprecise shots.
He's not cold enough to time Pac properly. Maybe too much of a warrior for that, who knows?

Floyd does all those things better, smarter, harder and faster at 130.

Easy pick in my mind.