As of today, what is your top 10 P4P List?

[xzworks]

Here's some names I've seen listed that I, myself, question their inclusion in the the top 10: Haye, Forrest, Mosley, Wright, Campbell, even Taylor.

haye for clearing up 200lbs.. forrest, i believe the light-mid linear champ and can do damage in welter aswell...

[Silencers]

Here's some names I've seen listed that I, myself, question their inclusion in the the top 10: Haye, Forrest, Mosley, Wright, Campbell, even Taylor.

Haye is the undisputed cruiserweight champion but he hasn't done enough to be in the top 10.

Forrest hasn't done much since his comeback, I'm still waiting to see how much he has left in his tank, scoring a controversial victory against Quartey then beating Baldomir and Piccirillio doesn't warrant his inclusion right now.

Mosley has enough left in the tank to be considered one of the best fighters still but he needs the big wins to get back into the top 10.

Out of all the names you mentioned Winky probably has the best case to be in the top 10 but to me his inactivity and recent record dropped him.

Taylor lost twice in a row but if he can make an impact at 168 he could make a case for himself being in the top 10.

Other names that I've seen in pound for pound lists that I don't think should be there just yet are Linares, Mijares, Calderon and Guzman.

[Njord777]

haye for clearing up 200lbs.. forrest, i believe the light-mid linear champ and can do damage in welter aswell...

I hear you but...there are too many other boxers deserving a place. It's not like cruiser weight has been the deepest division. He cleaned it up...but...still. Forrest hasn't done enough yet to earn the spot even if you think he will soon.

[frankpaganini]

Here's mine:



1. Floyd
2. Hopkins
3. Wright
4. Pacquiao
5. Mosley
6. Taylor
7. Cotto
8. Pavlik
9. Campbell
10. Calzaghe





Post yours.

i disagree with this list for the most part...

how can taylor be on the top 10 list? and ahead of pavlik at that? how does calzaghe drop ALL THE WAY to number 10?

campbell? really?....REALLY? he beats one guy and he goes to number 9?

how does pacquiao drop to 4th?

hopkins at number 2?

wright at 3?

wright is 1-1-1 in his last 3 fights...

i will post my list in a few mintues...

but i think this list is way off...

[OmnipotentFloyd]

#1 Floyd Mayweather

[frankpaganini]

Heres my list:

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Bernard Hopkins
6. Miguel Cotto
7. Israel Vasquez
8. Kelly Pavlik
9. Rafael Marquez
10. Wladimir Klitschko

in my opinion (and im sure a good 90% of all posters) will agree my list (while it may be a tad bit off in some opinions) is far my accurate than your dream of a list...

by looking at your list i have come to one of three conclusions...

either:

A) this is a joke of some kind

B) you are extremely biased to certain fighters on your list

C) you know little to nothing about boxing...

[demirturk]

hopkins 2???? lol

[demirturk]

1 floyd , 2 joe .
thats it for me

[J_CON]

Here's some names I've seen listed that I, myself, question their inclusion in the the top 10: Haye, Forrest, Mosley, Wright, Campbell, even Taylor.

Wright maybe but the others definately should not be in the top 10.

[T-97]

Mayweather
Pacquiao
Calzaghe
JMM
Hopkins
Vazquez
Cotto
Rafael Marquez
Pavlik
Hatton

I agree with this list