Bad Decisions

[MentalExecution]

What are some of the worst decisions youve seen in boxing over the years?

Ill start it off by saying the Whitaker-Chavez bout which ended in a majority draw. Me personally I had the bout at 119 to 110 to Whitaker.

[T-97]

I made this thread ages ago lol.

Yeah Chavez-Whittaker was bad and so was De La Hoya-Mosley 2/sturm. I don't think these ones are bad decisions but i bet people will but these up:
De La Hoya-Whittaker
De La Hoya-Quartey
Hatton-Collonzo
Mayweather-Castillo 1

[Silencers]

I made this thread ages ago lol.

Yeah Chavez-Whittaker was bad and so was De La Hoya-Mosley 2/sturm. I don't think these ones are bad decisions but i bet people will but these up:
De La Hoya-Whittaker
De La Hoya-Quartey
Hatton-Collonzo
Mayweather-Castillo 1

DLH vs Mosley 2 and DLH vs Sturm were bad.

Whitaker vs Ramirez 1
Lewis vs Holyfield 1
Ottke vs Reid

[TheGreatA]

Jersey Joe Walcott vs Joe Louis I
Walcott presented Louis a puzzle that the aging Joe couldn't solve and coasted his way to a seemingly lopsided decision. Two judges gave it to Louis who had already left the ring...
Louis and Walcott had a rematch and Louis won it by KO after being badly behind on points.


Floyd Patterson vs Jimmy Ellis
Patterson was robbed of his 3rd world title by the referee who happened to be the only judge (the unofficial judges all gave the fight to Patterson).

There were many bad decisions in the early 1900's but there isn't much footage of those fights so I won't say anything about them.

Nelson vs Fenech I was ugly.

[Silencers]

Foreman vs Briggs.
Leonard vs Hearns 2.
Santa Cruz vs Casamayor.
Forrest vs Quartey.

[T-97]

Jersey Joe Walcott vs Joe Louis I
Walcott presented Louis a puzzle that the aging Joe couldn't solve and coasted his way to a seemingly lopsided decision. Two judges gave it to Louis who had already left the ring...
Louis and Walcott had a rematch and Louis won it by KO after being badly behind on points.

Joe Louis left the ring because 'He didn't realise they had to wait', no joke that what he said. I agree though, as much as i love Joe Louis he lost that first fight. The first Arturo Godoy fight was also a bit fishy.....

[pins0099]

Recent......

Paulie Mallinaggi vs Herman N'goudjo

Marquez vs Pac I & II

[Flab]

Marquez vs PacMan 1 & 2.
Marquez vs Chris John
Marquez vs Freddie Norwood
Barrera vs Morales 1
Lewis vs Holyfield

[Darkstar]

De La Hoya beat Ike Quartey,Whitaker and Mosley. He lost to Felix Sturm, he should have never fought at middleweight.

Mayorga-Spinks was a really bad decision.

[Flab]

de la Hoya vs Mayweather!