♥boxing♥ Why don't you tell me...

[Fox McCloud]

what logic you use to say that Calzaghe passes Mayweather if he beats Pavlik.

Is it your argument that he was P4P #1 after he beat Kessler, before Mayweather beat Hatton?

Because on December 8th, Mayweather beat the #8 P4P fighter coming up in weight.

Calzaghe would be doing the EXACT same thing, except Pavlik is only #9.

So, if you would be so kind, please explain to me what the difference would be in the two, and why you would have Calzaghe passing Mayweather after doing that.

[GodOfWar]

wtf was hatton ranked number 8? hahahaha, maybe because pavlik went through harder competition then hatton. And hatton got alot of gifts. For one I had him losing against collzao and I personally felt like urango beat him. Thats just my opinion, wow he was ranked 8? Why because he beat a shot castillo by knock out?

And hattons been ducking witter for the longest ****ing time, pavlik hasn't ducked his hardest competition. He went for the hardest fighting zertuche, miranda, and taylor*twice*

[Fox McCloud]

wtf was hatton ranked number 8? hahahaha, maybe because pavlik went through harder competition then hatton. And hatton got alot of gifts. For one I had him losing against collzao and I personally felt like urango beat him. Thats just my opinion, wow he was ranked 8? Why because he beat a shot castillo by knock out?

And hattons been ducking witter for the longest ****ing time, pavlik hasn't ducked his hardest competition. He went for the hardest fighting zertuche, miranda, and taylor*twice*

You think Taylor was a more established better fight than Kostya Tszyu?

Hatton was ranked #8 by the ring by the way.

I was just curious. The general mood since the Mayweather-Hatton is that Hatton is still a good fighter, just a tremendously bad fighter north of 140. Basically, he was too small to be fighting at 147 against Floyd. If you think that Ricky Hatton is just a bad fighter, then fair enough, I can see where you are coming from. But if your argument is that Hatton was just too small to compete at 147, I'm not sure how you can move Calzaghe over Mayweather for doing pretty much the same thing that Mayweather just did in December.

[GodOfWar]

Kostya Tszyu was a shot ass fighter, poor example. His biggest wins were against two shot fighters castillo and tszyu. And I rank floyd at the top, he beat a bigger man named oscar and made oscar look like ****. Oscar looked like he was afraid in the ring at fighting the younger smaller fighter

[Fox McCloud]

Kostya Tszyu was a shot ass fighter, poor example. His biggest wins were against two shot fighters castillo and tszyu.

Okay, but even so... do you think that Ricky Hatton is a bad fighter in general, or just at 147? That really is the deciding factor in what I am asking.

[GodOfWar]

Okay, but even so... do you think that Ricky Hatton is a bad fighter in general, or just at 147? That really is the deciding factor in what I am asking.

He's not bad, hes just far from great. I'll say he is a b - level fighter and will never reach anything higher then that. So, I think he is a good fighter in general but I still believe junior witter ko's his ass and probably does it quicker then floyd, but no fault to floyd because that ref broke them up way too much and would never let either of them fight their in close battle.

[Fox McCloud]

He's not bad, hes just far from great. I'll say he is a b - level fighter and will never reach anything higher then that. So, I think he is a good fighter in general but I still believe junior witter ko's his ass and probably does it quicker then floyd, but no fault to floyd because that ref broke them up way too much and would never let either of them fight their in close battle.

Okay, fair enough. I wasn't calling you out, I just saw a big similarity in Calzaghe-Pavlik and Mayweather-Hatton, and I was curious what difference you saw between the two.

By the way, Calzaghe ****s Pavlik up if they end up fighting.

[GodOfWar]

By the way, Calzaghe ****s Pavlik up if they end up fighting.

Well, almost everyone knows that except a few of kellys nutt-hugging fans. Thats a fight Calzaghe will chase after but I doubt the contract will be signed, team pavlik will avoid a fight with calzaghe.