Who is the most overrated champion?

[Scott9945]

Zsolt Erdei. Some people think he's the 'lineal champ'...but if he was the champ, then I just stripped him for fighting **** competition over and over and not even pretending or trying to fight credible opponents.

and its not even like he has an easy time with them. he has problems in almost every one of his matches, from what Ive read.

I would agree with Erdei, except that most of the world has never even heard of his overprotected ass. My choice would be Ricardo Torres, who is still getting by on his suprising effort against Cotto years ago.

[ianblake]

super overrated

[Dynamite Kid]

super overrated

Malignaggi

u have to be rated before u can be overated

[RodBarker]

Ricky Hatton , he beat Kostya when he was ready in a foul fest , apart from him his resume is cherry picked all the way to Mayweather who exposed him , now the cherry picking will resume while he ducks the WC of his division .

He is a good tough fighter , but not the machine the hype trys to portray , will loose when he fights another fighter thats in his prime .

[Left2body]

Well out of the Champions NOT TITILIST, Sam Peters is a titlist/belt holder not a champion, but out of the champions I would say Casamayor. Not that he is over-rated he had an under-rated career but he is just not himself anymore and I beleive he is the most likely to lose his belt in his next defence.

The second most likely to lose his title would be Hatton, who would have legit difficulties with any of the other top jrWW's..., Malignagi/Torres/Witter/Holt. But he still has the ability to beat them because he isn't diminished as a fighter, his problems are just coming from better fighters........where as Casamayor is diminished and he is gonna fight guys that would've challenged him if he were prime.

[BmoreBrawler]

Mayweather, here's why:

Even though you can make a great case for him to be p4p #1, people act like you're crazy if you say that maybe Calzaghe or Pacquiao are #1.

To say that Mayweather has PROVEN through his accomplishments that he is UNDISPUTED p4p #1 is overrating him IMO.

[MikeBrew328]

Mayweather, here's why:

Even though you can make a great case for him to be p4p #1, people act like you're crazy if you say that maybe Calzaghe or Pacquiao are #1.

To say that Mayweather has PROVEN through his accomplishments that he is UNDISPUTED p4p #1 is overrating him IMO.

Calzaghe doesn't have a quarter of the resume Floyd's got, and Pacquiao has numerous legit defeats.

Floyd is undisputed the best fighter of this era regardless of weight class, get over it

[MikeBrew328]

I think Kelly Pavlik is not overrated but will get outboxed and lose the title. He showed in the Taylor rematch he's very basic and not very adaptable. He doesn't fight very well going backwards either.

[BmoreBrawler]

Quintana. I think he got lucky against a very green Williams who couldnt deal with his slickness.

[Tmb04]

Joe Calzaghe...