Where Do You Rank Cotto P4P?

[DLT]

Cotto is the weirdest guy in boxing in terms of P4P. Behind Floyd he is easily talked about more then anyone right now and everyone thinks he is the real deal but his P4P ranking seems to be a mystery. Where do you guys rank him? Is he 1, 2, 3, top 5, top 10? Do you guys have him over Floyd, Calzaghe, Pac, Hopkins, JMM, Wlad, Raffy, Izzy, Donaire, and so on?

[Silencers]

He's top 10 for me.

[xEDDIEx]

id put him in the top 5

[DLT]

Its weird because you never really hear people talk about him in a P4P sense but as a regular fighter alot of people talk about him like he's the best out there right now so I just wonder where people would rank him. I guess though that a P4P ranking would be different then what you really think he is anyway though right? I mean, you may think he's the best out there P4P but you might not rank him that way because you think another guy has accomplished more.

I personaly would rank him on what you think he really is. Even if you think a Calzaghe or Pac has a better resume but you think Cotto is the better fighter then I think you should rank Cotto higher since thats what its really about. Who is the better guy P4P

[Greatwhitehope]

Number 6ish.

[Left2body]

Ranking the p4p after the 1st and 2nd is like ranking the WelterWeight division after 1st or 2nd.

Most people can agree on the top 1 or 2 for both even if you dont like the boxers but after that its too subjective for anyone to really debate with anyone else.

Its pretty clear cut that PBF is first and I also think its pretty clear cut that Cotto aint number 2. I think after the 1st place p4p list is meaningless anyway.

[the giant one]

i have him 3rd behind floyd and calzaghe

[KESSLER]

I'd say top 10

[QuCongee]

#1 Joe Calzaghe
#2 Floyd Mayweather
#3 Manny Paquiao
#4 Kelly Pavlik
#5 Miguel Cotto

[T-97]

I have him at 7 due to his lack of top opposition, by the end of the year if he has taken Tony out i mught move him up higher.