The Official Zab Judah V Shane Mosley Poll!

[wmute]

ya, pretty much. but shane is getting old, so that helps

I can see that, but Shane being tough is what worries me, and that won't go away for a few more years.

[P4PKING_2008]

oh yeah? elaborate please...

More speed, power, foot speed, talent. Need I say anymore?

[wmute]

More speed, power, foot speed, talent. Need I say anymore?

Yes, you forgot to explain why Judah isnt p4p with all his talent...

If he lost to an old Carlos Baldomir while fighting for the undisputed WW championship, he can surely lose to an old Shane Mosley in a non-title fight.

[P4PKING_2008]

Yes, you forgot to explain why Judah isnt p4p with all his talent...

If he lost to an old Carlos Baldomir while fighting for the undisputed WW championship, he can surely lose to an old Shane Mosley in a non-title fight.

Why would he be at the top p4p? He should be with his talent, no question.

[revs1227]

Cuz Zab can do it. just watch........

they dont call him super 4 nothin judah judah judah judah!!!!!!!!

[The Fix]

as always, i got my boy zab.

[wmute]

Why would he be at the top p4p? He should be with his talent, no question.

Exactly.

With that talent, why is he not p4p?

For the same reason he lost to Baldomir, Spinks, got up instead of waiting against Zoo, had a close fight with Corley.

All of the above are nowhere near his combination of speed, reflexes and power.

For this same reason he might very well lose to someone as tough as Mosley.

[P4PKING_2008]

Bump for more votes.

[Njord777]

Zab is definitely a live opponent; he's got speed, power and skill- but he almost always fails when he steps up. That mental game just isn't focused. Based on pure skill I could see him putting up a great fight and winning, but when you look at his losses it's hard to imagine Mosley, who still looks good, losing. I mean, honestly, their last common opponent is pretty telling. I've heard people say Zab looked better...but Cotto knocked him out. I feel like Mosley did a good job, he just got worn down by the constant pressure and wasn't quite young enough to steal the decision. Mosley should be able to weather an early storm, though, and take a decently wide decision.

[ElGranLuchador]

this bout its like mayorga vs vargas 2 hopefully it will be as entertaining as that fight was
my vote goes for mosley just using common sense