Judges discrepencies....

[MELLY-MEL...]

how many rounds between the judges cards are acceptable? as in the duddy fight for example, 2 judges have duddy up by 6 points, yet one has it a draw? wtf! i personally feel that about 2 points difference is acceptable, and would go as far as 3 at the very most! what are your thoughts this guys? how can we have such big gaps and it be ok?

[Silencers]

3 at most.

[neils7147933]

how many rounds between the judges cards are acceptable? as in the duddy fight for example, 2 judges have duddy up by 6 points, yet one has it a draw? wtf! i personally feel that about 2 points difference is acceptable, and would go as far as 3 at the very most! what are your thoughts this guys? how can we have such big gaps and it be ok?

There is no set number - it depends on the fight. If two fighters went 12 rounds that were all competitive - who could say two people scoring the fight 120-108 different ways weren't doing a good job judging?

That being said, I have seen some fights where I don't understand where the judging goes one way or the other, but just because two judges differ on points doesn't mean that one of the them is inept