Joe Calzaghe should be P4P #2...

[RichCCFC]

Joe Calzaghe has achieved far more than Manny Pacquiao who doesn't even hold a belt at Super Featherweight! Calzaghe has cleaned out the SMW division setting all kind of records in doing so while Pacquiao is lucky his division is so talented yet a lot of people still think Guzman and Marquez would beat him. Most of the people on this board agree that no one can touch Calzaghe from 160-175 while Pacquiao would be lucky to clean up just the one and wouldn't dare fight Juan Diaz @ 135.

The only reason Calzaghe isn't above Pacquiao in the mythical P4P list is because he hasn't fought old shot fighters like Pacquiao...

[dansapien]

i'm a calzaghe fan, but manny deserves to be above him.

[jcarr71]

Why do you care how other people's P4P lists look? It sounds like he's number two on yours. Every single persons P4P list is different. There is no one list with any particular meaning.

[Haterfree]

P4p is all just opinions. But Joe C is definitely #2 on my personal list.

[Fox McCloud]

Pacquiao's first win over Barrera is better than anything Calzaghe has accomplished.

[jcarr71]

For kicks, and it is absolutely fine to disagree with this; it doesn't matter. But, again, for kicks... Here is my top 10 P4P.

1 Floyd Mayweather Jr
2 Joe Calzaghe
3 Juan Manuel Marquez
4 Manny Pacquiao
5 Kelly Pavlik
6 Bernard Hopkins
7 Wladimir Klitschko
8 Miguel Cotto
9 Israel Vazquez
10 Cristian Mijares

[P4PKING_2008]

What from fighting bums your whole career? If he stepped and fought the opposition B-Hop has you might have a point but he has been defending his title against people like Manfredo for ****s sake. Come on man, you know better.

[Dorian]

i'm a calzaghe fan, but manny deserves to be above him.

agreed
Manny faced far better competition and dominated them all

[sparked_85]

I have Manny above Joe. He has the 'names'

Joe is putting cherries on the cake at this point.

[jcarr71]

Well there are two ways of looking at P4P lists people. You can make resume lists, or you can make talent comparison lists. You can remove resume and just rank people on the faulty dream of who you think would win fights if their weights magically equalized overnight if you want. You don't have to do it by who has beat better boxers.